Use of Force Continuum: Graham v. Connor, Reasonableness, and Liability

The use-of-force continuum is the tiered framework law enforcement agencies use to match an officer’s response to the resistance or threat a person presents. Most versions run through five levels, from an officer simply showing up in uniform to deadly force, and the model is meant to flex with the situation rather than march up a staircase. Officers are expected to use the lowest level that will safely resolve the encounter, and courts judge their choices by what a reasonable officer would have done with the same information in the same moment.

The Five Levels of Force

Agencies label and subdivide these tiers differently, but the standard continuum moves through five general stages. Each level is a greater intrusion on the person’s liberty than the one before it.

  • Officer presence. A uniformed officer or marked patrol vehicle on scene. No words, no contact. The visible authority of law enforcement is meant to deter or calm on its own.
  • Verbal commands. Spoken instructions aimed at compliance, from conversational requests to short, loud directives. Tone and word choice often decide whether the encounter escalates at all.
  • Empty-hand control. Physical contact without weapons. Lower-risk techniques include guiding someone by the arm or applying joint locks; higher-risk techniques include strikes. This level comes into play when a person ignores verbal commands and resists.
  • Intermediate weapons. Tools designed to control without lethal force, including batons, pepper spray, and conducted energy devices. These carry real medical risks, and people with cardiac implants or pre-existing heart conditions face elevated danger from conducted energy devices in particular.
  • Deadly force. Any action likely to cause death or serious bodily injury. Firearms are the obvious example, but a vehicle used to ram someone or repeated blows to the head can qualify. It’s reserved for situations where the officer reasonably believes someone faces an imminent threat of death or serious physical harm.

How Officers Move Between Levels

The levels are not a staircase an officer has to climb one step at a time. If someone pulls a knife in the middle of a conversation, the officer doesn’t need to cycle through empty-hand techniques and pepper spray before drawing a firearm. The continuum describes the range of available options, not a required sequence.

Early versions were drawn as a ladder, and officers and juries sometimes read the ladder as requiring step-by-step progression. Many agencies have since moved to circular or matrix-style models that emphasize jumping to any appropriate level based on the threat, then dropping back down the moment the threat decreases. The core principle is the same across every model: force should rise and fall with the situation.

In practice, these transitions happen fast. An officer might open with verbal commands, shift to empty-hand control when someone pulls away, and return to verbal commands seconds later once resistance stops. The continuum’s real value is giving officers a shared vocabulary for describing what they did and why, and giving supervisors and courts a framework for evaluating whether those choices made sense.

The Legal Standard Under Graham v. Connor

The test for whether an officer’s force was acceptable comes from the Supreme Court’s 1989 decision in Graham v. Connor. The Court held that every excessive-force claim against law enforcement must be evaluated under the Fourth Amendment’s “objective reasonableness” standard.1Federal Law Enforcement Training Centers. Use of Force – Part II Courts don’t ask whether the officer made the best possible decision. They ask whether a reasonable officer facing the same facts, in the same moment, could have made the same choice.

The standard comes with a critical limit: no hindsight. Courts evaluate what the officer knew at the time, not what came to light afterward. If an officer detained someone on reasonable suspicion that turned out to be wrong, the later discovery doesn’t automatically make the force unconstitutional.1Federal Law Enforcement Training Centers. Use of Force – Part II The flip side holds too. An officer can’t justify force by pointing to information learned later, like a weapon discovered only during a subsequent search.

Deadly Force Against Fleeing Suspects

Four years before Graham, the Supreme Court set the outer limits of deadly force in Tennessee v. Garner (1985). The case involved a Memphis officer who shot and killed a teenager fleeing from a nighttime burglary. The Court struck down the old common-law rule that let officers use deadly force against any fleeing felon, holding that deadly force against a fleeing suspect is unconstitutional unless the officer has probable cause to believe the person poses a significant threat of death or serious physical injury to the officer or others.2Legal Information Institute. Tennessee v. Garner, 471 U.S. 1 (1985)

In practical terms, an officer can’t shoot a fleeing shoplifter or someone running from a minor crime. Deadly force to prevent escape is only permissible when the person is dangerous, and even then the officer must give a warning if feasible.3Justia. Tennessee v. Garner, 471 U.S. 1 (1985) Together, Garner and Graham are the two pillars courts use to evaluate virtually every use-of-force case.

What Makes Force Reasonable

The Graham decision identified three factors courts weigh when judging whether force was reasonable. They aren’t the only factors, but they’re the starting point for nearly every analysis.

Severity of the Crime

The more serious the suspected offense, the stronger the government’s interest in detaining the person, and the more intrusive the officer’s response can be. An officer investigating an armed robbery has more justification for a forceful approach than one responding to a noise complaint.4Federal Law Enforcement Training Centers. Part II The Objective Test

Immediate Threat

Whether the person poses an immediate danger to the officer or bystanders is widely considered the most important of the three factors. Courts look at whether the person had a weapon, made threatening movements, or created conditions that put others at risk.1Federal Law Enforcement Training Centers. Use of Force – Part II

Resistance and Flight

Active resistance and attempts to flee both affect the calculus. Someone who tenses up and pulls away presents a different challenge than someone throwing punches, and courts treat those situations differently. Flight carries its own weight because a fleeing person can endanger bystanders and frustrate the government’s ability to investigate or execute a warrant.1Federal Law Enforcement Training Centers. Use of Force – Part II

Other Considerations

Beyond the three Graham factors, officers weigh practical realities: the relative size and physical ability of the officer and the person, whether other officers are present, the environment (a crowded sidewalk versus an open field), and the person’s apparent mental or emotional state. Training matters too. An experienced officer who knows wrist-control techniques has options a rookie might not, and courts sometimes consider that gap when evaluating what was reasonable.

Mental Health Crises and De-Escalation

Encounters with people in a mental health or behavioral crisis call for a different approach than a standard arrest. Someone in crisis may not understand or be able to follow commands, and escalating force often makes things worse for everyone involved.

Congress addressed this with the Law Enforcement De-Escalation Training Act of 2022, which directed the Department of Justice to develop or identify training for encounters involving people in mental health or suicidal crisis, as well as people with disabilities.5COPS Office. Community Policing Development: Implementation of De-escalation Training Act Program The required training emphasizes alternatives to physical force.

Executive Order 14074, signed in May 2022, reinforced these principles for federal agencies by requiring use-of-force policies that reflect the value of preserving human life, annual evidence-based training, and early-warning systems to flag officers whose use-of-force patterns suggest a problem. The same order banned chokeholds and carotid restraints for federal law enforcement except where deadly force is authorized, and restricted no-knock warrant entries.6GovInfo. Executive Order 14074 – Advancing Effective, Accountable Policing and Criminal Justice Practices Those requirements apply directly only to federal agencies, but they set expectations that influence state and local policy.

Duty to Intervene and Render Aid

Officers also have obligations about what other officers are doing. The Department of Justice’s use-of-force policy states that officers must recognize and act on an affirmative duty to intervene to prevent or stop any officer from using force that violates the Constitution, federal law, or department policy.7United States Department of Justice. 1-16.000 – Department of Justice Policy on Use of Force Standing by while a colleague uses excessive force is itself a policy violation.

After force has been used, officers have a duty to get medical help to the person subjected to it. Federal courts have generally held that officers satisfy this obligation by promptly calling for emergency medical services or transporting the injured person to a hospital. Officers who did neither have faced successful lawsuits. Many departments go further than the legal minimum, requiring basic first aid at the scene while waiting for paramedics.

Consequences When Force Crosses the Line

Officers who use excessive force face potential consequences on three fronts: criminal prosecution, civil liability, and internal discipline. These can run at the same time.

Federal Criminal Charges

Under federal law, an officer who willfully uses excessive force while acting in an official capacity can be prosecuted for depriving someone of their constitutional rights. Penalties scale with the harm caused: up to one year in prison for a base violation, up to ten years if bodily injury results or a dangerous weapon was involved, and up to life in prison or a death sentence if the victim dies.8Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 U.S. Code 242 – Deprivation of Rights Under Color of Law

Civil Lawsuits

Separately from any criminal case, the person subjected to excessive force can sue the officer for money damages. Federal law allows anyone whose constitutional rights were violated by someone acting under government authority to bring a civil action for compensation.9Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 42 U.S. Code 1983 – Civil Action for Deprivation of Rights These lawsuits are the primary tool for holding individual officers, and sometimes their departments, financially accountable. The statute of limitations varies by state but generally falls between two and four years.

Qualified Immunity

Officers sued for excessive force almost always raise qualified immunity as a defense. The doctrine shields government officials from personal liability unless their conduct violated a “clearly established” right that a reasonable person would have known about.10Library of Congress. Harlow v. Fitzgerald, 457 U.S. 800 (1982) In practice, “clearly established” is a high bar. Courts often require a prior case with very similar facts where a court already ruled the same type of conduct unconstitutional. Officers who acted in a reasonable but mistaken way keep their immunity; those who showed clear incompetence or knowingly violated the law do not. Qualified immunity remains one of the most debated areas in civil rights law because it can block otherwise valid claims before they reach a jury.

Internal Discipline

Even when criminal charges aren’t filed and civil suits don’t succeed, officers can face administrative consequences from their own departments. Penalties range from retraining and suspension to demotion, termination, and in the most serious cases decertification, which strips the officer’s license to work in law enforcement anywhere in the state.11U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Community Oriented Policing Services. Standards and Guidelines for Internal Affairs – Recommendations from a Community of Practice Agencies typically use progressive discipline, where penalties increase with repeated violations, and many maintain penalty matrices to keep treatment consistent across similar cases.