What Does En Banc Mean? Rehearings, Panels, and Appeals

An en banc hearing is a session in which all active judges of a federal appeals court decide a case together, rather than the usual three-judge panel. The phrase is French for “on the bench.” Federal rules treat en banc review as disfavored and reserve it for two narrow situations: resolving a conflict within the circuit’s own case law, or deciding a question of exceptional importance.

When a Court Sits En Banc

Federal rules limit en banc review to two circumstances. The first is intra-circuit conflict. When two three-judge panels have issued contradictory rulings on the same legal question, lawyers and lower courts are left guessing which to follow, and the full court steps in to establish a single rule for the circuit.1Legal Information Institute (LII) / Cornell Law School. Rule 40 – Panel Rehearing; En Banc Determination

The second is a question of “exceptional importance.” The phrase is deliberately open-ended, but it covers cases where the legal stakes extend well beyond the parties: challenges to major federal regulations, cases that could reshape constitutional protections, and issues on which different circuits have reached different conclusions. The federal rules specifically note that a conflict with another circuit’s ruling can support a finding of exceptional importance.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 28 USC App Fed R App P Rule 35 – En Banc Determination

Who Sits on the Court

In most circuits, every active judge participates when a case is heard en banc. Senior judges, who carry a reduced caseload, generally cannot vote on whether to grant en banc review and do not sit on the en banc court. The one exception is a senior judge who was part of the original three-judge panel; that judge may participate in the en banc hearing and decision.3U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. IOP 35.1 – En Banc Poll and Decision

The Ninth Circuit is the outlier. With roughly 29 active judges, assembling the entire bench is impractical, so federal law allows any circuit with more than 15 active judges to conduct en banc review with a smaller group. The Ninth Circuit uses an 11-judge panel: the chief judge and 10 others selected at random.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 28 USC 46 – Assignment of Judges; Panels; Hearings; Quorum

How to Request a Rehearing En Banc

En banc review usually follows a three-judge panel decision. The most common path is a petition for rehearing en banc, filed within 14 days after the panel’s judgment is entered. When the federal government is a party, the deadline extends to 45 days.1Legal Information Institute (LII) / Cornell Law School. Rule 40 – Panel Rehearing; En Banc Determination

The petition itself has strict formatting rules. A computer-produced petition cannot exceed 3,900 words. If a party files both a petition for panel rehearing and a petition for rehearing en banc, the two together count as a single document toward that word limit unless a local circuit rule requires separate filings.5Justia Case Law. Rule 35 – En Banc Determination

Filing a petition alone doesn’t force the court to act. No vote is taken unless an active judge on the court requests one. For rehearing to proceed, a majority of the circuit’s active judges must vote in favor. This is where most petitions quietly die. Even busy circuits grant en banc rehearing only a handful of times a year.1Legal Information Institute (LII) / Cornell Law School. Rule 40 – Panel Rehearing; En Banc Determination

A separate path exists for initial hearing en banc, in which a case goes directly to the full court without a panel decision first. The request must be filed by the date the party’s principal brief is due, and the court can also order it on its own. The federal rules say this “ordinarily will not be ordered,” and it is even rarer than rehearing en banc.1Legal Information Institute (LII) / Cornell Law School. Rule 40 – Panel Rehearing; En Banc Determination

What Happens If Review Is Granted

Once the court votes to rehear a case en banc, the original panel’s decision is automatically vacated. In practical terms, the three-judge panel’s opinion no longer exists as law. The full court starts fresh, reviewing the case from the trial court’s judgment rather than second-guessing the panel.6United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit. Rule 40 – Panel Rehearing; En Banc Determination

The en banc court then schedules new briefing and oral argument. After deliberation, the full court issues a decision that becomes the definitive law of the circuit. Every three-judge panel and every district court within that circuit must follow it. Any prior panel opinion that conflicts with the en banc ruling is overruled. This is what makes en banc review powerful: it is the only way a circuit can correct its own precedent without waiting for the Supreme Court to intervene.

When an en banc court splits evenly, the result depends on the procedural posture. An equally divided en banc court generally affirms the lower court’s decision, but that affirmance carries no precedential weight. The legal question remains unresolved, and other panels are free to take a different direction on the same issue later.

Appealing an En Banc Decision

A party unhappy with the en banc result has one option left: petitioning the U.S. Supreme Court for a writ of certiorari. The deadline is 90 days after the en banc judgment is entered. If a petition for panel rehearing was denied before the en banc process, the 90-day clock still runs from the date of the en banc judgment itself.7Legal Information Institute (LII) at Cornell Law School. Rule 13 – Review on Certiorari: Time for Petitioning

The Supreme Court agrees to hear only a small fraction of the cases brought to it each year, but en banc decisions are among the more likely candidates for review, particularly when the ruling deepens a split between circuits or strikes down a federal statute. An en banc decision that resolves an intercircuit conflict can cut the other way, actually reducing the Supreme Court’s incentive to get involved, since the full court has already given the issue more thorough treatment than a three-judge panel would have.