At a default hearing in a civil case, the judge reviews the plaintiff’s evidence without the defendant there to contest it, decides whether the proof supports the claim, and sets the amount of any judgment. The proceeding is short, one-sided, and more active on the judge’s part than a typical hearing, because no one is on the other side to push back. If a judgment comes out of it, it is binding and enforceable like any other.
What the Judge Does at the Hearing
The defendant is almost always absent. That absence is what brought the case here in the first place. The plaintiff presents the case directly to the judge, who decides whether the evidence justifies the relief being requested.
With no opposing party challenging the evidence, the judge fills that gap. Expect pointed questions about how damages were calculated, what supports each figure, and whether the submitted documents are authenticated. Judges probe rather than rubber-stamp, because the defendant, by defaulting, has lost the ability to contest the facts. That makes the judge’s scrutiny the only check against inflated or fabricated claims.
Hearings can involve live testimony, but most run on affidavits and documentary evidence. The judge may conduct an accounting, determine damages, or verify specific allegations in the complaint.1Cornell Law Institute. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 55 In some jurisdictions, either side can request a jury to decide damages in a default case, though that is uncommon.
What the Plaintiff Has to Prove
A default does not mean the plaintiff automatically wins. The earlier entry of default establishes liability based on the complaint’s allegations, but the plaintiff still carries the full burden of proving damages. Plaintiffs who walk in assuming the hard part is over tend to stumble here.
For fixed-amount claims like unpaid debts or bounced checks, the evidence is straightforward: the contract, the invoices, a ledger of what is owed. For claims where the number is not predetermined, such as personal injury, emotional distress, or lost business opportunities, the plaintiff has to build a real evidentiary case. That means medical bills and records, expert testimony on future care costs, business financial statements showing lost revenue, or similar documentation that lets the judge calculate a specific figure rather than guess at one.
Affidavits do most of the work. A sworn statement from the plaintiff detailing losses, or from an expert explaining a damages calculation, can substitute for live testimony, but the affiant has to have firsthand knowledge. Secondhand accounts do not count. Financial records, photographs, correspondence, and contracts round out the package. Organization matters: judges handling default calendars often have dozens of cases that day, and a clear evidence packet makes a real difference.
The Ceiling on What the Judge Can Award
One rule catches plaintiffs off guard. A default judgment cannot give you more than you asked for in the complaint. Federal Rule 54(c) says a default judgment “must not differ in kind from, or exceed in amount, what is demanded in the pleadings.”2Cornell Law Institute. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 54 A complaint that asked for $50,000 caps the recovery at $50,000, even if the evidence at the hearing would support more. The original complaint sets the ceiling.
Judges generally award two kinds of relief. Monetary damages cover financial losses: unpaid debts, medical expenses, lost wages, property damage. The judge scrutinizes those figures to ensure they reflect actual losses rather than speculation. Equitable relief, meaning court orders requiring someone to do or stop doing something, applies when money alone cannot fix the problem. A judge might order a former business partner to return proprietary files or prohibit a competitor from using a stolen trade secret. Either way, the remedy has to be proportionate to what was actually proved.
Entry of Default Is Not Yet a Judgment
People use “default judgment” to describe the whole process, but courts treat it as two separate steps, and the distinction changes what options a defendant has.
The first step is the entry of default. When a defendant files no response and does not defend the case, the plaintiff asks the court clerk to record that failure. The clerk notes the default, and from that point every factual allegation in the complaint is treated as admitted for purposes of liability. The defendant has not been found liable at trial. They are treated as having conceded the plaintiff’s version by staying silent. That admission covers liability only, not damages, which the plaintiff still has to prove.
The second step is the default judgment. For a specific, calculable amount like $5,000 on an unpaid invoice, the clerk can enter judgment without a hearing, provided the plaintiff submits an affidavit of the amount due and the defendant is not a minor or legally incapacitated person.1Cornell Law Institute. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 55 For everything else, the plaintiff has to ask a judge for a hearing.
One notice rule often gets missed. If the defendant made any kind of appearance in the case, even a phone call or a letter to the court, the plaintiff must serve written notice of the default judgment application at least seven days before the hearing.1Cornell Law Institute. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 55 Skipping that notice can get the whole judgment thrown out later.
Getting a Default or Default Judgment Undone
If a default has been entered against you, the situation is serious but rarely hopeless. Courts prefer deciding cases on the merits and generally look for reasons to give defendants another chance. The standard depends on how far the process has run.
Setting Aside an Entry of Default
If the clerk has entered your default but no judgment has issued yet, the bar is relatively low. You have to show “good cause” for the failure to respond.1Cornell Law Institute. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 55 Courts typically look at three things: whether your failure to respond was willful or just a mistake, whether you have a legitimate defense, and whether the plaintiff would be unfairly harmed by reopening the case. A defendant who simply missed the deadline and has a plausible defense has a decent shot. One who ignored the case on purpose does not.
Vacating a Default Judgment
Once an actual judgment is in place, the standard tightens. You have to file a motion under Federal Rule 60(b), which lets a court set aside a final judgment for specific reasons:3Cornell Law Institute. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 60
- Mistake or excusable neglect, meaning a reasonable explanation for the missed deadline such as a medical emergency, a mail failure, or genuine confusion about the response date.
- Newly discovered evidence that could change the outcome and could not have been found earlier with reasonable effort.
- Fraud or misrepresentation by the plaintiff in obtaining the judgment.
- A void judgment, where the court lacked jurisdiction over you or the subject matter.
- Satisfaction or changed circumstances, where the judgment has been paid or the basis for it has been reversed.
- Any other justifying reason, a catch-all for extraordinary circumstances.
For the first three grounds, the motion must be filed within one year of the judgment. The rest require filing within a “reasonable time,” interpreted according to the circumstances. In every case, you also have to show a real defense to the lawsuit, because courts will not reopen a case just to reach the same result. Speed matters. The longer you wait after learning of the judgment, the harder it is to convince a judge that your delay was reasonable.
Protections for Military Servicemembers
Federal law adds safeguards for active-duty military members who cannot respond because of their service. Before entering a default judgment, the court must receive an affidavit from the plaintiff stating whether the defendant is in military service, or saying so if the plaintiff cannot tell.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 50 USC 3931 – Protection of Servicemembers Against Default Judgments Lying on that affidavit is a federal offense.
When it appears the defendant is on active duty, the court cannot enter a default judgment until it appoints an attorney to represent the absent servicemember, and that appointed attorney cannot waive the servicemember’s defenses or bind them to a result they never agreed to.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 50 USC 3931 – Protection of Servicemembers Against Default Judgments
If a default judgment is entered against a servicemember during active duty or within 60 days after service ends, the court must reopen the case if the servicemember shows that military service materially affected the ability to defend and that there is a legitimate defense. The application to reopen has to be filed within 90 days after service ends.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 50 USC 3931 – Protection of Servicemembers Against Default Judgments
What Comes After the Judgment
A default judgment does not trigger immediate collection. In federal court, an automatic 30-day stay follows entry of judgment, during which the plaintiff cannot take any enforcement action.5Cornell Law Institute. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 62 That window gives the losing side time to pay voluntarily or move to set the judgment aside. For a defendant who just learned about the judgment, this is the window to act.
After the stay, the standard tool for collecting a money judgment is a writ of execution.6Cornell Law Institute. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 69 It authorizes law enforcement to seize and sell non-exempt property belonging to the judgment debtor, following the law of the state where the court sits. What is reachable, what is protected, and how garnishment works vary considerably. Most states exempt a primary residence up to a specified value, basic personal property, and retirement accounts.
For non-monetary judgments, such as an order to return property or stop a business practice, the court uses its contempt power to compel compliance. A party who defies the order can face fines or jail. In complex matters, the court may appoint a receiver to oversee compliance. Judgments typically remain enforceable for 10 to 20 years depending on the state and can often be renewed, so a debtor cannot simply wait them out.