What Happens During an Arbitration Hearing?

An arbitration hearing follows a set sequence: opening statements, the claimant’s evidence and witnesses, the respondent’s evidence and witnesses, cross-examination at each stage, rebuttal, and closing arguments. After the record closes, the arbitrator deliberates privately and issues a written decision called an award. What happens during an arbitration hearing resembles a bench trial, but with looser evidence rules, a faster pace, and far less formality. Most arbitrations resolve within about a year from filing to final award.

Before the Hearing Starts

By the time the hearing day arrives, a lot has already been decided. At a preliminary conference held weeks or months earlier, the arbitrator and the parties set the hearing date and location, agreed on whether testimony would be live or by video, worked out document exchange, and decided whether any threshold legal issues could be resolved early to narrow the dispute. The arbitrator then issued a procedural order that serves as the roadmap for the case.1American Arbitration Association. AAA Preliminary Hearing Practice Guide

In the weeks before the hearing, both sides exchange copies of every document they plan to use and identify every witness they intend to call. Under FINRA’s rules, for example, this exchange must happen at least 20 days before the first hearing date.2FINRA. FINRA Rule 12514 – Prehearing Exchange of Documents and Witness Lists Show up with a surprise document or an unidentified witness, and the arbitrator can exclude them unless you demonstrate a good reason for the late disclosure, such as needing the evidence for rebuttal based on something that came up at the hearing itself.

You have the right to represent yourself without a lawyer, and major arbitration providers like the AAA explicitly permit it. For a dispute involving significant money or complex legal issues, going in without counsel is a risk most people shouldn’t take.

Opening Statements

The hearing opens with the arbitrator’s introductory remarks: procedural ground rules, confirmation of the issues in dispute, and the swearing in of witnesses. Each side then gives an opening statement. The claimant (the party who filed) goes first, followed by the respondent. Opening statements outline what each side intends to prove and preview the key evidence. They are a roadmap, not a closing argument.

The Claimant’s Case

Under the AAA’s Commercial Rules, the claimant puts on evidence to support its claim, then the respondent presents evidence in defense.3American Arbitration Association. AAA Commercial Arbitration Rules – Rule R-33 In practice, the claimant calls witnesses, walks them through their testimony on direct examination, and introduces documentary exhibits. Each exhibit is marked for identification, shown to the other side, and admitted by the arbitrator after any objections are resolved.

The respondent then cross-examines each of the claimant’s witnesses. Cross-examination is where most of the real testing of a case happens. The other side can challenge the witness’s credibility, highlight inconsistencies, and draw out facts favorable to their own position. The arbitrator can also ask questions at any point to clarify testimony.4FINRA. FINRA Hearing Procedure Script – 3 Member Panel

Evidence rules are looser than in court. Arbitrators aren’t bound by the formal rules of evidence that govern courtrooms. They can admit anything they consider relevant and material, and they can exclude what they find cumulative or beside the point.5American Arbitration Association. AAA Commercial Arbitration Rules – Rule R-35 Evidence a court would exclude might still come in.

The Respondent’s Case

Once the claimant rests, the respondent presents its own case using the same format: direct examination of witnesses, introduction of exhibits, and submission to cross-examination by the claimant. If the respondent filed a counterclaim, this is when they present evidence supporting it. The arbitrator has discretion to vary the order of presentation if the circumstances call for it, but the claimant-first structure is standard.

Rebuttal and Closing Arguments

After both sides present their cases, the claimant may offer rebuttal evidence to address specific points raised during the respondent’s presentation. The hearing then moves to closing arguments, where each side summarizes what they believe the evidence proved and why the arbitrator should rule in their favor. The claimant goes first and may reserve part of its closing for rebuttal after the respondent finishes.4FINRA. FINRA Hearing Procedure Script – 3 Member Panel

In more complex cases, the arbitrator may allow or request post-hearing briefs instead of or in addition to oral closings. These are written submissions filed after the hearing that let the parties make detailed legal arguments tied to the evidence in the record. When briefs are permitted, the hearing record doesn’t officially close until the arbitrator receives the last submission.6American Arbitration Association. AAA Commercial Arbitration Rules – Rule R-40

The Arbitrator’s Role During the Hearing

The arbitrator isn’t a passive listener. They manage the procedural flow, rule on objections, decide what evidence gets admitted, and control the pace. They can bifurcate the proceedings to handle a dispositive issue first, potentially ending the case without a full hearing. They can reorder the presentation of evidence if it makes the issues clearer. And they can ask their own questions of any witness at any time.

Arbitrators also have the power to compel attendance. Under the Federal Arbitration Act, an arbitrator can issue a written summons requiring any person to appear and bring relevant documents. If the person ignores the summons, the arbitrator can petition a federal district court to compel attendance or hold the person in contempt.7Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 9 USC 7 – Witnesses Before Arbitrators This power is narrower than a court’s subpoena authority, but it gives arbitrators real teeth when a critical witness or document holder refuses to cooperate.

The hearing itself is private. Unlike court proceedings, arbitration happens in a conference room and the filings stay between the parties. Private does not automatically mean confidential, though. Unless the arbitration rules, a state law, or the parties’ own agreement impose confidentiality, either side can generally discuss the proceedings publicly.8American Bar Association. Confidentiality in U.S. Arbitration

Virtual Hearings

Arbitration hearings increasingly take place by video. The AAA rules explicitly allow testimony and evidence presentation through video, audio, or other electronic means, provided all parties get a full opportunity to present their case and cross-examine witnesses.3American Arbitration Association. AAA Commercial Arbitration Rules – Rule R-33 Whether a hearing goes virtual or stays in person is typically decided at the preliminary conference, though pandemic-era shifts made remote proceedings far more common and accepted across the field.

After the Hearing: The Award

Once the record closes, the arbitrator deliberates and issues a written decision called an award. Timelines vary by provider. Under FINRA’s rules, the panel must issue the award within 30 business days after the record closes.9FINRA. FINRA – Decision and Award The AAA rules don’t impose an identical deadline, but the expectation is prompt resolution. Awards don’t always include detailed reasoning. Under federal law, the arbitrator doesn’t need to explain the rationale unless the applicable rules or the parties’ agreement require a reasoned decision.

Whether the award ends the dispute depends on whether the arbitration is binding or non-binding. In binding arbitration, the award is final and enforceable like a court judgment. If the losing party doesn’t comply, the winning party can go to court and ask a judge to confirm the award. Under the FAA, the court must confirm the award unless grounds exist to vacate or modify it, and the winning party has one year from the date of the award to file for confirmation.10Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 9 USC 9 – Award of Arbitrators; Confirmation; Jurisdiction; Procedure Non-binding arbitration works differently: the award is advisory, and either party can reject it and pursue litigation.

Appeal rights are severely restricted. The Federal Arbitration Act allows a court to throw out an award only in extreme situations: fraud or corruption, evident partiality in the arbitrator, the arbitrator’s refusal to hear material evidence, or the arbitrator exceeding the scope of authority granted by the agreement.11GovInfo. 9 USC 10 – Vacation of Awards Parties cannot privately agree to give courts broader review power. The Supreme Court shut that door in Hall Street Associates v. Mattel, holding that the FAA’s grounds for vacatur are the exclusive basis for judicial review.12JAMS Mediation, Arbitration, ADR Services. Appealing an Arbitration Award: Early Planning and Agreement Are Key Disagreeing with the arbitrator’s reading of the facts or the law is not enough. A court can modify or correct an award for clerical errors, like a miscalculation of figures, but the core legal conclusions stand even if a reviewing judge would have decided differently.13Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 9 USC 11 – Modification or Correction of Award