What Happens If a Jury Is Hung Twice: Retrial and Double Jeopardy

When a jury is hung twice, the judge declares a second mistrial and the case lands back on the prosecutor’s desk with no conviction and no acquittal. From there, the government chooses among three paths: try the case a third time, negotiate a plea, or drop the charges. A third trial is legally permitted but uncommon, and it is usually reserved for the most serious offenses.

What a Second Mistrial Actually Does to the Case

A hung jury produces no verdict. When the foreperson confirms the jurors are irreconcilably split, the judge discharges the jury and declares a mistrial. The case reverts to its pretrial posture. The defendant is neither guilty nor acquitted, and the charges remain pending until the prosecutor decides what to do next.

Mechanically, a second mistrial looks identical to the first. What changes is leverage. The government’s evidence has now failed to convince two separate groups of citizens, and both sides know it.

Why a Third Trial Does Not Violate Double Jeopardy

The Fifth Amendment bars trying a person twice for the same offense, but the Supreme Court has long held that a hung jury does not count as a first “try” for double jeopardy purposes. The foundational case is United States v. Perez (1824), which ruled that discharging a deadlocked jury is not a bar to a later trial as long as there was a “manifest necessity” for ending the trial. A hopelessly split jury is the textbook example.1Justia. United States v. Perez, 22 U.S. 579 (1824)

The Court restated the rule 160 years later in Richardson v. United States: “Neither the failure of the jury to reach a verdict nor a trial court’s declaration of a mistrial following a hung jury is an event that terminates the original jeopardy.”2Justia. Richardson v. United States, 468 U.S. 317 (1984) Jeopardy attaches when the jury is sworn in, but it does not end without a verdict.3Legal Information Institute. Reprosecution After Mistrial

The practical consequence: there is no constitutional cap on how many times the government can retry a case after successive hung juries. The limits are practical, not legal.

What Prosecutors Usually Do After Two Hung Juries

The decision whether to try a third time belongs to the prosecutor. No judge or defendant can force the choice. Among criminal practitioners, two retrials is widely treated as the practical ceiling. A third attempt is uncommon and almost always limited to the most serious charges, like murder, where the alleged conduct justifies the expense and public interest in a resolution.

Several factors drive the call:

  • The jury vote breakdown. A shift from mostly-for-acquittal in the first trial to mostly-for-conviction in the second may suggest a better presentation could get a conviction. A flat or worsening split points the other way.
  • New evidence or witnesses. Without something new, the same case has now failed twice.
  • The seriousness of the charge. Violent felonies get retried more readily than property crimes.
  • Cost and resources. Each retrial consumes witness preparation, expert fees, and weeks of attorney time.

After two mistrials, the realistic outcomes are a plea agreement or a dismissal rather than another trial.

Plea Bargains

Two mistrials give the defense leverage. The prosecutor knows a conviction at a third trial is uncertain, and the defendant may be worn down by the process. That combination produces conditions for compromise: a guilty plea to a lesser charge, a reduced sentence recommendation, or both. Accepting a deal trades the uncertainty of another trial for a known outcome.

Dismissal: With or Without Prejudice

The prosecutor can also drop the case. Under the federal rules, the government may dismiss an indictment with the court’s approval.4Legal Information Institute. Rule 48 – Dismissal The critical detail is the type of dismissal. A dismissal with prejudice permanently bars the government from refiling the same charges. A dismissal without prejudice leaves the door open to refile later, as long as the statute of limitations has not expired. Defense attorneys will push hard for dismissal with prejudice after two hung juries so that the case cannot come back.

What the Defense Can Do After the Second Mistrial

Motion for Judgment of Acquittal

Under Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 29, if a jury has been discharged without returning a verdict, the court “may enter a judgment of acquittal.” The defendant has 14 days after the jury is discharged to file the motion, and the defendant does not need to have raised the issue before the case went to the jury.5Legal Information Institute. Rule 29 – Motion for a Judgment of Acquittal

The standard is high. A judge can grant acquittal only if the evidence was legally insufficient, meaning no reasonable jury could have convicted. Two hung juries alone do not meet that bar. A split jury signals disagreement about the evidence, not that the evidence was so weak no rational person could convict. Still, after two failed trials, defense attorneys almost always file the motion, and on rare occasions a judge who has sat through both trials concludes the government’s proof genuinely falls short.

Revisiting Bail

A mistrial does not automatically change a defendant’s custody status. A defendant out on bail generally stays out; a defendant in custody stays in custody unless the court modifies the conditions. After two mistrials, defense counsel will often argue that continued pretrial detention is unjustified given the government’s inability to secure a conviction. Judges have discretion to adjust bail, and two failed trials can weigh in the defendant’s favor.

Can a Judge Block the Third Trial?

This is where defendants often pin their hopes, and where the law is less favorable than they expect. In the federal system, no statute or rule gives judges explicit authority to stop the government from retrying a case after multiple hung juries. Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 31(b)(3) actually reinforces the prosecutor’s position, allowing the government to retry any defendant on any count the jury could not agree on.

Most federal courts have concluded they lack authority to block a retrial on due process grounds alone. The prevailing view is that a court can dismiss an indictment under its inherent authority only if the government engaged in misconduct, the defendant was prejudiced by that misconduct, and no less severe remedy exists. Repeated retrials without prosecutorial bad faith do not meet that test, and no federal court has found a due process violation based solely on successive retrials after hung juries.

Some state courts have broader authority. A handful of states allow judges to dismiss charges “in the interest of justice” under state procedural rules, which can give a judge room to intervene after repeated mistrials. Even in those states, dismissing after only two hung juries would be unusual, and the defense would need to show something beyond mere repetition.

How Soon the Third Trial Must Start

If the government does decide to go again, the clock is short. Under the Speedy Trial Act, the retrial must begin within 70 days of the date the mistrial is declared.6Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 3161 – Time Limits for Information or Indictment and for Trial Certain delays are excluded, including time spent on pretrial motions or continuances granted by the judge, but the 70-day baseline is a concrete protection against being left in limbo.

The Sixth Amendment’s speedy trial guarantee provides an additional constitutional backstop. After two mistrials, the cumulative wait is long, and a defendant who has been in custody the entire time has a stronger argument that further delay is unconstitutional, especially combined with the government’s two failures to convict.

Put together, the picture after a second hung jury is this: the government can legally try again, but usually will not. The leverage has shifted. Most of these cases end in a negotiated plea or a dismissal, and the ones that proceed to a third trial tend to be the ones the government cannot afford to walk away from.