What Happens on a Hung Jury? Mistrial, Retrial, and Acquittal

When a jury is hung, the judge declares a mistrial, the jury is discharged, and the case resets to its pretrial posture with the original charges still in place. Nothing has been decided: there is no conviction and no acquittal. The prosecutor then chooses whether to retry the case, offer a plea, or drop the charges, and in the meantime you remain a defendant under the same bail conditions you had going into trial.

What the Judge Does Before Giving Up on the Jury

Judges rarely declare a mistrial the first time jurors report they are stuck. The usual move is to send them back with further instructions. The best-known of these is the Allen charge, which comes from the 1896 Supreme Court case Allen v. United States. It tells jurors in the minority to seriously reconsider their position in light of the majority view, while reminding them not to abandon a genuinely held belief just to end deliberations.1Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center. Allen v. United States 164 U.S. 492

Many states have banned the Allen charge on the ground that it pressures holdouts; federal courts still allow it, and jurisdictions that prohibit it use softer instructions that encourage continued deliberation without singling anyone out. How long the judge keeps the jury working is largely up to the judge. The Supreme Court has said trial judges get broad discretion here and are not required to force a minimum deliberation period, poll each juror, or try any particular method before calling it.2Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center. Renico v. Lett 559 U.S. 766

What a Mistrial Actually Means

Once the judge concludes the jury is truly deadlocked, the trial ends without a legally valid outcome. The jury is discharged, but the indictment stays on the books. You are still charged. The case snaps back to roughly the same position it was in before opening statements.

The Supreme Court held in United States v. Perez (1824) that a hung jury creates “manifest necessity” to end the trial, which preserves the government’s ability to try you again. In the Court’s words, the defendant “has not been convicted or acquitted, and may again be put upon his defence.”3Legal Information Institute. United States v. Perez 22 U.S. 579

Why a Retrial Doesn’t Violate Double Jeopardy

The Fifth Amendment’s Double Jeopardy Clause bars the government from trying you twice for the same offense, but a hung jury does not trigger that protection. Because the first trial produced no verdict, jeopardy is not considered to have ended, and a second trial is treated as a continuation of the same effort rather than a new one.4Legal Information Institute. U.S. Constitution Annotated – Reprosecution After Mistrial

There is one narrow exception. In Oregon v. Kennedy (1982), the Supreme Court held that double jeopardy bars a retrial if the prosecutor deliberately provoked the defense into asking for a mistrial. The misconduct has to be specifically intended to goad the defense into that request, not just aggressive or sloppy lawyering.5Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center. Oregon v. Kennedy 456 U.S. 667 This almost never applies when the mistrial came from a genuine jury deadlock rather than the prosecution’s conduct.

What the Prosecutor Decides Next

After a mistrial, the decision belongs to the prosecutor. Three paths are open.

  • Retry the case with a new jury. This is the most common outcome when the evidence was strong. Prosecutors look closely at how the first jury split: a lopsided vote toward conviction usually produces a retrial, while an even split or one leaning toward acquittal makes the calculation harder.
  • Offer a plea deal. A hung jury gives both sides leverage. The prosecution has shown it can mount a credible case; the defense has shown it can create doubt. That dynamic often moves the parties toward a negotiated plea, often to a reduced charge or lighter sentence.
  • Dismiss the charges. If the trial exposed real weaknesses, the prosecutor may conclude a conviction is unlikely even on a second try. A dismissal without prejudice leaves the door open to refile if new evidence emerges; a dismissal with prejudice ends the case for good.

Where You Stand Between the Trials

Because the charges are still active, your pretrial situation generally continues. If you were out on bail, you usually stay out under the same conditions while the prosecutor decides what to do. If you were in custody, you typically stay there, though your attorney can request a new bail hearing. A judge may be willing to revisit the terms in light of how the trial went; a jury leaning toward acquittal, for example, can support an argument for lower bail or release.

You remain subject to every pretrial obligation you had before: court appearances, release conditions, and availability for a potential retrial. The limbo can last months.

How Long the Government Has To Retry You

Federal law does not let prosecutors sit on the case indefinitely. Under the Speedy Trial Act, a retrial after a mistrial must start within 70 days from the date the mistrial becomes final.6Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 U.S.C. 3161 – Time Limits for Information or Indictment and for Trial Certain periods are excluded from that clock, including time spent on pretrial motions and continuances granted for good cause. States have their own speedy trial rules with their own timelines. If the government misses the deadline, you can move to dismiss.

When the Jury Hangs on Some Counts but Not Others

If you are charged with several counts, the jury may agree on some and deadlock on others. Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 31 allows the jury to return a verdict on the counts it has resolved and report that it cannot agree on the rest.7Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 31 – Jury Verdict The judge then declares a mistrial only on the deadlocked counts.

You can therefore be convicted on some counts and face a retrial on others. Acquittals on any count are final and cannot be retried. Whether the prosecutor pursues the hung counts often depends on what the jury did decide; a conviction on the main charge can make a retrial on a lesser one pointless.

Asking the Judge for an Acquittal Instead

A hung jury is not the only option for the defense after deliberations end. Under Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 29, you can ask the judge to enter a judgment of acquittal on the ground that the evidence was insufficient to support a conviction. The motion can be filed within 14 days after the jury is discharged, and you do not have to have raised it during trial to raise it afterward.8Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 29 – Motion for a Judgment of Acquittal

The standard is tougher than showing the jury was split. The judge has to conclude that no reasonable jury could have found guilt beyond a reasonable doubt on the evidence presented. If granted, the result is an acquittal, which is final and cannot be appealed by the prosecution. These motions do not succeed often, but when the government’s case was genuinely thin, one can end the matter without a second trial.

Is There a Limit on How Many Retrials You Can Face?

No statute or rule caps how many times the government can retry a case after successive hung juries. Rule 31 says the government “may retry any defendant on any count on which the jury could not agree,” and courts have read that as imposing no numerical limit.7Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 31 – Jury Verdict In theory, a prosecutor could try the same case three or four times.

There is a constitutional backstop. The Supreme Court noted in Bartkus v. Illinois that at some point repeated prosecutions become so burdensome they violate due process. Where that line sits has never been precisely defined, and courts give prosecutors wide latitude. In practice, most cases end after one or two retrials, either with a conviction, a plea, or a decision by the prosecutor that a jury will never unanimously convict. A third or fourth trial is rare and draws serious judicial scrutiny.