What Is a Criminalist? Duties, Evidence, and Salary

A criminalist is a forensic scientist who analyzes physical evidence from crime scenes using laboratory techniques drawn from chemistry, biology, and physics. The Bureau of Labor Statistics groups these professionals under the broader category of forensic science technicians, a field that employed roughly 20,700 people in 2024 and paid a median salary of $67,440.1Bureau of Labor Statistics. Forensic Science Technicians: Occupational Outlook Handbook Rather than investigating in the field, criminalists spend their time in labs running tests on blood, drugs, firearms, DNA, and other materials collected by police. Their conclusions can decide a criminal case.

What the Work Looks Like

The core of the job is turning physical objects into scientific conclusions. A detective hands the lab a bag of white powder, a bloodstained shirt, or a fired cartridge case, and the criminalist determines what it is, where it came from, and whether it links to a suspect. That work falls into two broad tasks: identification, which asks what a substance is, and individualization, which asks whether an item can be tied to a specific person or source through comparison.

On a given day a criminalist might extract DNA from a swab, run a chemical test to confirm a powder is methamphetamine, or compare microscopic marks on two bullet casings to see if they came from the same gun. Each analysis follows strict protocols meant to produce results that hold up in court. Every step is documented, from the condition of evidence on arrival to the instruments used and the readings they produced. Sloppy documentation or a broken chain of custody can get otherwise solid evidence thrown out at trial.

Results also have to be reproducible. Another qualified analyst following the same procedure should reach the same conclusion. That standard is what separates forensic science from guesswork, and it’s why lab reports carry the weight they do in legal proceedings.

Criminalist vs. Crime Scene Investigator

The two roles get confused often, but they are distinct. Crime scene investigators work in the field. They photograph scenes, dust for fingerprints, collect biological samples, bag shell casings, and document everything before it is disturbed. Their focus is proper evidence handling and chain of custody, and many come from law enforcement or criminal justice backgrounds rather than hard science.

Criminalists pick up where CSIs leave off. They receive the packaged evidence and analyze it in a controlled laboratory using specialized instruments. The job requires advanced education in a scientific discipline, strong analytical skills, and the ability to write detailed reports and testify as an expert witness. CSIs gather evidence in the field; criminalists analyze it in the lab.

Types of Evidence Criminalists Analyze

Most criminalists specialize. A few of the main areas:

DNA

Criminalists extract genetic material from biological evidence like blood, saliva, or skin cells and develop a profile that can identify a suspect or exclude an innocent person. Profiles are searched against the Combined DNA Index System (CODIS), an FBI-managed program that operates local, state, and national DNA databases. When a crime-scene profile matches a convicted offender or arrestee in the database, the lab follows confirmation procedures and reports the match to investigators. CODIS also links unsolved cases to each other when DNA from different scenes matches, even before a suspect is identified.2Federal Bureau of Investigation. CODIS and NDIS Fact Sheet

Firearms and Toolmarks

When a gun is fired, the barrel leaves microscopic marks on the bullet and the firing mechanism stamps unique impressions on the cartridge case. Criminalists compare these marks under a comparison microscope to determine whether a recovered bullet or casing was fired from a specific weapon. The same discipline covers toolmarks left at scenes by screwdrivers, pry bars, or bolt cutters.

Drug Chemistry

Seized drug analysis is one of the highest-volume tasks in any forensic lab. When police confiscate pills, powders, or plant material, a criminalist confirms whether a controlled substance is present and identifies exactly what it is. Analysts typically begin with presumptive color tests and move to definitive methods like gas chromatography and mass spectrometry.

Toxicology

Toxicologists screen blood, urine, and other fluids for drugs, alcohol, or poisons. The specialty is central to DUI cases, drug-facilitated assaults, and suspicious deaths. Precise concentration measurements matter because legal consequences often turn on specific thresholds.

Trace Evidence

Trace evidence covers the small materials that transfer between people, objects, and environments during a crime: hair, fibers, glass fragments, paint chips, soil. A single textile fiber on a victim can tie a suspect to a scene if it matches the suspect’s clothing. Trace evidence rarely closes a case on its own, but combined with other results it can be powerfully corroborative.

Digital and Multimedia Evidence

As crime involves technology more and more, many labs have expanded into digital evidence, including data recovered from computers, phones, and surveillance systems. The National Institute of Justice has noted that law enforcement agencies are building digital evidence collection and analysis into their forensic infrastructure.3National Institute of Justice. Digital and Multimedia Evidence Some agencies run digital forensics as a separate unit; others cross-train criminalists to handle both.

Where Criminalists Work

Most criminalists work in government-run laboratories at the local, state, or federal level. Municipal, county, and regional agencies run labs that support local investigations. Federal agencies, including the FBI, operate larger facilities that handle complex or multi-jurisdictional cases. These are climate-controlled environments equipped with instruments like gas chromatographs, mass spectrometers, and high-powered microscopes.

Some criminalists work in medical examiner offices, analyzing physical evidence recovered during autopsies. Others move into private consulting, providing independent analysis for defense attorneys or civil litigation. The job occasionally calls for travel to active crime scenes when fragile or unusual evidence needs oversight during collection, but the lab is home base for the vast majority of the work.

Education and Certification

A bachelor’s degree in a natural science is the standard entry point. The Bureau of Labor Statistics lists a bachelor’s as the typical entry-level education for forensic science technicians.1Bureau of Labor Statistics. Forensic Science Technicians: Occupational Outlook Handbook Chemistry, biology, and biochemistry degrees are the most competitive, and forensic science programs are widely accepted when they include substantial coursework in the hard sciences. Employers look for a solid foundation in instrumental analysis, organic chemistry, and statistics, plus strong technical writing.

Most agencies prefer hands-on lab experience before hiring. Internships at forensic labs or medical examiner offices give candidates exposure to evidence handling, chain of custody procedures, and the workflow of a functioning lab. Advanced roles, particularly at federal agencies or in specialties like DNA, may require a master’s degree.

Professional certification through the American Board of Criminalistics (ABC) is a widely recognized credential. The ABC has developed certification exams in specialties including forensic biology, drug identification, fire debris analysis, and trace evidence.4National Institute of Justice. Certification of DNA and Other Forensic Specialists Maintaining certification requires continuing education. It isn’t always mandatory for employment, but it signals competence and can affect advancement.

Salary and Job Outlook

The median annual salary for forensic science technicians was $67,440 as of May 2024.1Bureau of Labor Statistics. Forensic Science Technicians: Occupational Outlook Handbook Pay varies considerably by geography, agency level, and specialty. Federal positions and labs in high-cost metro areas tend to pay more; entry-level roles at smaller municipal agencies start lower. Criminalists with advanced degrees or certifications in DNA or toxicology generally earn above the median.

Employment is projected to grow 13 percent from 2024 to 2034, which the BLS describes as much faster than average.1Bureau of Labor Statistics. Forensic Science Technicians: Occupational Outlook Handbook That growth reflects the increasing use of forensic evidence in criminal cases and the expanding scope of what labs can analyze. The field is small in absolute numbers, so competition for openings is stiff.

How Criminalists Contribute in Court

After completing an analysis, a criminalist writes a formal laboratory report detailing the methods, results, and conclusions. These reports become part of discovery, meaning both prosecution and defense receive and scrutinize them. The writing needs to be scientifically precise while remaining understandable to attorneys and judges who lack scientific training. Errors or ambiguity can trigger challenges before the evidence ever reaches a jury.

Courts evaluate forensic testimony under Federal Rule of Evidence 702, which allows a qualified expert to testify when specialized knowledge will help the jury understand the evidence, the testimony rests on sufficient facts and reliable methods, and those methods were properly applied to the case.5Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Evidence Rule 702 – Testimony by Expert Witnesses Judges also act as gatekeepers under the Daubert standard, evaluating whether an expert’s methodology has been tested, peer-reviewed, and generally accepted before allowing the testimony.6National Institute of Justice. Law 101: Legal Guide for the Forensic Expert – Daubert and Kumho Decisions

During cross-examination, opposing counsel probes a criminalist’s qualifications, the condition of the evidence, and whether chain of custody held at every step. Preparation and documentation pay off here. A criminalist who can explain why a particular test was chosen, how it works, and what the results mean is far more effective than one who hides behind jargon.

Why Accuracy Carries Such Weight

The stakes are high. Flawed work can convict innocent people or let guilty ones walk free. A National Institute of Justice study examining 732 wrongful conviction cases found that 635 of them involved errors related to forensic evidence.7National Institute of Justice. The Impact of False or Misleading Forensic Evidence on Wrongful Convictions

Error rates vary by discipline. Hair comparison, bite mark analysis, and blood spatter interpretation produced some of the highest rates of problematic conclusions. Almost all latent fingerprint errors in the study involved fraud or uncertified examiners rather than flaws in the underlying science. Seized drug analysis errors overwhelmingly originated from field testing kits rather than laboratory work.7National Institute of Justice. The Impact of False or Misleading Forensic Evidence on Wrongful Convictions Those findings are why lab accreditation, certification, ethics enforcement, and rigorous quality control exist. They are safeguards against the most serious harm a forensic professional can cause.