A good faith settlement is a court’s determination that a deal between the plaintiff and one defendant in a multi-defendant lawsuit is fair and reasonable given that defendant’s likely share of the blame. Once a judge signs off, the settling defendant walks away with real legal protection, the plaintiff’s recovery from the remaining defendants gets reduced by the settlement amount, and the shape of the rest of the case changes accordingly.
When the Issue Comes Up
This only matters when more than one defendant could be responsible for the same injury. A one-plaintiff, one-defendant case either settles or goes to trial; no court has to weigh in on whether the number is fair. The question appears when several parties share potential liability and one of them wants to pay something and exit early.
Typical settings include car accidents involving multiple drivers or a driver and a vehicle manufacturer, construction defect cases naming the general contractor along with subcontractors and architects, medical malpractice suits against both a doctor and a hospital, and product liability claims against a manufacturer and a distributor. In each one, the plaintiff says several parties contributed to the same harm. When one of them cuts a deal and leaves, the others have a direct stake in whether that deal was fair or whether it quietly shifted a disproportionate share of liability onto them.
How Courts Decide a Settlement Is in Good Faith
A signed settlement agreement isn’t automatically in good faith. A court has to evaluate it. The core question is whether the amount lands somewhere in the reasonable range of what the settling defendant would owe based on their share of fault. Courts don’t demand precision. The usual standard is whether the figure is “in the ballpark” rather than grossly disproportionate to the defendant’s likely liability.
The widely cited factors come from a 1985 California case, Tech-Bilt, Inc. v. Woodward-Clyde & Associates. They include a rough estimate of the plaintiff’s total potential recovery, the settling defendant’s proportional share of liability, the amount actually being paid, a recognition that defendants typically pay less in settlement than they would after losing at trial, the settling defendant’s financial condition and insurance policy limits, and any signs of collusion, fraud, or misconduct aimed at the remaining defendants.1GovInfo. United States District Court Order – Valerie George, et al., v. Sonoma County Sheriff’s Dept., et al.
Not every jurisdiction uses identical factors. Some states apply a stricter proportionality test that compares the settlement to the jury’s eventual fault allocation; others take a broader “totality of the circumstances” view; a few will approve anything that isn’t outright collusive or fraudulent. The common thread is that the settlement cannot be so low that it forces the remaining defendants to subsidize the settling defendant’s exit.
What the Settling Defendant Gets: The Contribution Bar
The main benefit of a good faith finding is protection from cross-claims by the other defendants. Two concepts drive this.
Contribution is the right of a defendant who paid more than their fair share of a judgment to force other defendants to chip in. If three defendants are each 33% at fault and one pays the whole judgment, that defendant can pursue the other two for their portions. Indemnity goes further: it shifts the entire loss to another party, usually under a contract or a special legal relationship.
When a court finds a settlement was made in good faith, the settling defendant is discharged from liability for contribution to any other defendant. The Uniform Contribution Among Tortfeasors Act, the model law behind contribution statutes in a majority of states, says a good faith settlement “discharges the tortfeasor to whom it is given from all liability for contribution to any other tortfeasor.” Even if the remaining defendants go to trial and lose badly, they cannot turn around and sue the settling defendant for a share of the verdict.
There’s an important limit. The contribution bar generally applies to claims based on shared fault in tort. If two defendants have a separate contractual indemnity agreement between them, a good faith finding may not shield the settling party from a breach-of-contract claim under that contract. Settling defendants sometimes assume they are fully protected when a pre-existing indemnity agreement can survive the good faith order.
What the Other Defendants Get: The Verdict Offset
A good faith settlement also changes the math for anyone still in the case. The plaintiff’s total damages award at trial is reduced by the dollar amount of the settlement. This credit, called an offset or setoff, keeps the plaintiff from collecting twice for the same harm.
In practice: a plaintiff settles with Defendant A for $75,000. The case goes to trial against Defendant B, and the jury awards $300,000 in total damages. The verdict is reduced by the $75,000 settlement, so the plaintiff collects only $225,000 from Defendant B. Total recovery stays at $300,000. The Uniform Contribution Among Tortfeasors Act codifies this by providing that a good faith release “reduces the claim against the others to the extent of any amount stipulated by the release.”
This is why non-settling defendants care about the settlement amount. A suspiciously low number means a smaller offset and a bigger bill for whoever stays in the case, which is exactly why they have the right to challenge the settlement’s good faith.
How a Court Approves the Settlement
Approval requires a formal motion, usually filed by the settling defendant. The motion is backed by evidence that the settlement falls within a reasonable range: the settlement agreement itself, information about the settling defendant’s finances and insurance limits, and often declarations from attorneys or experts explaining how the amount lines up with the defendant’s proportional liability.
All non-settling defendants get notice and an opportunity to object. In most jurisdictions, the burden sits on the party challenging the settlement, not the party seeking approval. A defendant objecting has to produce actual evidence that the number is unreasonably low, collusive, or otherwise unfair. Generalized complaints about wishing the settling defendant were paying more will not work.
The court can hold a hearing, review affidavits, and weigh any counter-evidence. The job is not a mini-trial on the merits and not an exact fault allocation. It’s a rougher, faster look designed to catch settlements clearly outside the ballpark.1GovInfo. United States District Court Order – Valerie George, et al., v. Sonoma County Sheriff’s Dept., et al.
What Happens if the Court Says No
A denial doesn’t void the settlement. The plaintiff and the settling defendant can still go through with the deal. What’s lost are the legal protections that made the early exit attractive. Without good faith approval, the settling defendant stays exposed to contribution and indemnity claims from the others. If the remaining defendants go to trial and pay more than their fair share, they can sue the settling defendant for the difference.
The settling defendant then has three choices. Renegotiate at a higher amount and run the good faith motion again. Go through with the original settlement and absorb the risk of future cross-claims. Or scrap the settlement and stay in the case through trial. Renegotiating is the most common outcome because neither the plaintiff nor the settling defendant wants the contribution exposure left open.
Mary Carter and Sliding Scale Agreements
Some settlement agreements aren’t straightforward. A “Mary Carter” agreement is a deal where the settling defendant’s final payment depends on the outcome of the trial against the remaining defendants. The settling defendant typically pays an initial amount but gets some of it back if the plaintiff wins a large verdict against the non-settling parties. The settling defendant may even stay in the case through trial, nominally adverse to the plaintiff but with a financial incentive aligned with the plaintiff’s success.
Courts are deeply skeptical of these arrangements. The problem is the alliance they create between the plaintiff and the supposedly adverse settling defendant, both of whom now benefit from a large verdict against whoever is left. Some courts have held that Mary Carter agreements cannot be good faith settlements at all, reasoning that they frustrate the goal of encouraging genuine settlements and function as collusive attempts to shift all liability onto the non-settling defendants.
Many jurisdictions require that any sliding scale or contingent settlement be disclosed to the court and all other parties before or during the good faith hearing. Failure to disclose is itself strong evidence of collusion and grounds for denying approval. If you’re a non-settling defendant and you suspect the settlement has strings attached, demand full disclosure of the agreement terms at the hearing.