A sidebar conversation in court is a brief, private discussion at the judge’s bench between the judge and the attorneys, held in lowered voices so the jury can’t hear. Lawyers ask for one whenever a legal issue needs to be worked out away from the jurors, most often a fight over whether a piece of evidence is admissible. The jury stays in the box and waits while the huddle happens a few feet away.
The point is to keep the trial moving. Sending the jury out of the room every time a procedural question comes up would waste hours over the course of a trial, and some objections can’t even be stated out loud without revealing the very information the objection is trying to keep out. The sidebar solves both problems at once.
Who Stands at the Bench
Three groups take part: the judge, the lead attorney for each side, and a court reporter. The lawyers step away from counsel table and approach the bench, where they speak quietly enough that the jury box can’t make out the words.
In a criminal trial, the defendant typically stays seated at the defense table. Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 43 permits this by exempting proceedings that involve “only a conference or hearing on a question of law” from the general rule that a defendant must be present at every stage of trial.1Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 43 – Defendant’s Presence
The court reporter is the participant people often forget about. The reporter either wheels a portable stenotype machine over to the bench or uses a dedicated microphone to pick up the conversation. Without a reporter capturing it, the exchange effectively didn’t happen for any purpose that matters later.
Why Attorneys Ask to Approach
The most common reason is an evidence dispute. If a witness is about to blurt out a prior arrest, offer hearsay, or stray into territory a pretrial ruling already closed off, one of the lawyers will ask to approach before the damage is done. The judge rules on whether the evidence comes in, and the jury never hears the argument. Letting jurors hear something that turns out to be inadmissible can taint a trial badly enough to force a mistrial, which is why both sides are quick to flag the issue.
Not every sidebar is high-stakes. Lawyers also use them for scheduling conflicts with the next witness, technical problems with an exhibit, or a request for a short recess. Handling that kind of housekeeping at the bench is faster than clearing the courtroom for it.
Judges sometimes call attorneys over for a different reason: to correct behavior or rein in a line of questioning that’s wandering. Doing it privately avoids embarrassing the lawyer in front of the jury, which can skew how the jurors feel about that side of the case.
How the Jury Is Kept from Overhearing
Lowered voices aren’t always enough, especially in a small courtroom. Some courts use a “husher,” a device that generates white noise to mask the conversation at the bench. The District of Columbia Superior Court describes its husher as “a white noise device intended to foster the confidentiality of conversations at the bench.”2Supreme Court of the United States. Brief for the United States in Opposition, Blades v. United States Other courtrooms pipe ambient sound through overhead speakers or just rely on distance and the natural background noise of the room. Either way, the jury sees the lawyers at the bench but hears nothing of substance.
Whether Sidebars Go on the Record
Federal law requires court reporters to record court sessions verbatim, including proceedings in criminal cases conducted in open court.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 28 USC 753 – Reporters Whether a specific sidebar gets recorded, though, is up to the judge. Some judges want every word captured. Others let portions of a bench conference go off the record, and federal transcript guidelines require the reporter to label the distinction explicitly.4United States District Court for the District of Montana. Transcript Format Guidelines
This matters on appeal. An appellate court can only review what appears in the transcript. If a sharp objection happens during an unrecorded sidebar, it legally never happened. Trial lawyers who sense the reporter didn’t catch something will repeat the important part on the record once the sidebar breaks up.
Sidebar or Send the Jury Out
When a legal issue has to stay away from the jury, a judge has two choices: hold a sidebar or excuse the jurors from the room. The sidebar is faster and less disruptive, which is why judges usually prefer it for quick rulings. The downside is that the hushed, hurried setting makes it harder to build a clean record. When a legal argument is complex or likely to be contested on appeal, experienced lawyers will often ask the judge to send the jury out so the discussion can happen at full volume with the reporter working in normal conditions.
Judges have broad discretion over which path to take, and they tend to lose patience with lawyers who want to clear the courtroom for every minor point. Knowing when to push for a full hearing and when to settle for a bench conference is part of the trial lawyer’s job.
The Rule Behind the Practice
No rule in the federal rulebook says courts shall hold sidebars. The practice exists because other rules force judges to keep certain information away from the jury. Federal Rule of Evidence 103(d) directs that “the court must conduct a jury trial so that inadmissible evidence is not suggested to the jury by any means.”5Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Evidence Rule 103 – Rulings on Evidence The sidebar is one of the most practical ways to meet that duty: when the grounds for an objection would themselves reveal something prejudicial, arguing the objection out loud defeats the whole purpose.
Rule 103 also requires a timely objection with specific grounds before any evidentiary error can be raised on appeal.5Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Evidence Rule 103 – Rulings on Evidence If a judge denies a request to approach, the attorney still has to state the objection clearly enough to preserve it, which puts the lawyer in the uncomfortable spot of saying in open court the very thing the sidebar was meant to avoid. Most handle it by keeping the on-the-record version short and vague.