Prosecution is how the government brings and pursues criminal charges against a person or organization accused of breaking the law, and understanding what prosecution is and how it works means following a case from the moment charges are considered through investigation, formal charging, pretrial procedure, plea negotiation or trial, and sentencing. The state takes on this work rather than leaving victims to pursue justice themselves. A prosecutor represents the public, not a particular victim, which is why a case can go forward even when the person harmed would rather it didn’t.
Who Runs a Criminal Case
Three figures drive a prosecution: the prosecutor, the defendant, and the judge.
At the federal level, U.S. Attorneys handle criminal cases within their districts.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 28 USC 547 – Duties In state court, the work goes to district attorneys, county prosecutors, or state attorneys general depending on the jurisdiction. These lawyers appear on behalf of “the People” or “the State.” The distinction isn’t ceremonial. It means the prosecutor’s job is to enforce the law fairly, not to win on any one person’s behalf.
The defendant is the person or entity facing charges. The Sixth Amendment guarantees a right to counsel, and if the defendant can’t afford a lawyer, the court appoints one. The defendant has no obligation to prove anything. The burden of proving guilt rests entirely on the government.
The judge referees. Judges decide what evidence the jury hears, settle disputes between the sides, and keep the proceedings within the rules. If the defendant is convicted, the judge imposes the sentence after weighing the offense, the defendant’s record, and any aggravating or mitigating facts.
Where Victims Fit
Victims are not parties to the case. A victim doesn’t file charges and doesn’t control whether the prosecution continues. Federal law does give victims specific rights: notice of court proceedings, the right to attend, and the right to be heard at bail, plea, and sentencing hearings. Prosecutors must also tell victims about any plea agreement or deferred prosecution.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 3771 – Crime Victims Rights Most states have adopted similar protections. These are rights to participate, not rights to decide.
How a Case Gets Charged
Before anyone sees a courtroom, the government has to clear procedural hurdles. The first is probable cause: enough evidence for a reasonable person to believe a crime occurred and the defendant committed it. From there, charges are formalized through either an information, which the prosecutor files directly, or an indictment, returned by a grand jury.
Grand Juries and Indictments
The Fifth Amendment requires a grand jury indictment for serious federal crimes.3Legal Information Institute. Fifth Amendment That requirement applies only in federal court. States can use grand juries or allow prosecutors to charge directly. A federal grand jury has between 16 and 23 members, and at least 12 must agree to return an indictment.4Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 6 – The Grand Jury The proceedings are secret, only the prosecutor presents evidence, and the defendant has no right to appear or cross-examine. The standard is probable cause, not proof beyond a reasonable doubt, which is one reason grand juries almost always return indictments when prosecutors ask them to.5LII / Legal Information Institute. Grand Jury Clause Doctrine and Practice
Initial Appearance and Arraignment
After arrest or charging, the defendant must be brought before a judge without unnecessary delay.6Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 5 – Initial Appearance At that first hearing the judge explains the charges, confirms the right to an attorney, and decides whether to detain or release the defendant pending trial. No plea is entered at this stage in felony cases.
Pleas come at arraignment, a separate hearing. The court confirms the defendant has the indictment or information, reads or explains the charges, and asks for a plea.7Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 10 – Arraignment Most defendants plead not guilty even if they later negotiate a resolution, because that plea sets the trial-preparation clock running.
Why Charges Vary Case to Case
One of the most consequential decisions in any prosecution happens before a courtroom gets involved. Prosecutors decide whether to charge, what to charge, and whether to offer a deal. This authority, called prosecutorial discretion, isn’t codified in a single statute. It’s a feature of the executive branch’s law-enforcement power, and courts give prosecutors wide room to use it.
A prosecutor can review a case after arrest and conclude the evidence isn’t strong enough, that a diversion program fits better, or that the facts justify a more serious charge than police recommended. A prosecutor can also move to dismiss charges already filed. Judges can accept or reject plea agreements, but they generally can’t force a prosecutor to bring or keep charges.8Congress.gov. Federal Prosecutorial Discretion – A Brief Overview This is why two people arrested for similar conduct can end up facing very different charges.
Deadlines That Constrain the Government
Two separate timing rules limit how long a prosecution can take.
The statute of limitations sets the outer window for bringing charges in the first place. For most federal crimes, the government has five years from the date of the offense to file an indictment or information.9Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 3282 – Offenses Not Capital Capital offenses have no statute of limitations.10United States Department of Justice Archives. Criminal Resource Manual 650 – Length of Limitations Period Many specific federal offenses have their own periods that override the five-year default. Tax evasion has a six-year window. Certain terrorism and fraud offenses run longer. State periods vary widely, though murder typically has no time limit anywhere. The clock usually starts when the crime is committed, not when it’s discovered, though some fraud offenses apply a discovery rule.
Once charges are filed, the Speedy Trial Act takes over. The government must file an indictment or information within 30 days of arrest, and trial must begin within 70 days after the indictment is filed or the defendant first appears in court, whichever comes later.11Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 3161 – Time Limits and Exclusions The statute lists numerous excludable delays — pretrial motions, competency evaluations, interlocutory appeals — so complex federal cases often take months or years without violating the Act. If the deadlines are missed without a valid exclusion, the charges must be dismissed.
Why Most Cases End in a Plea
Trials are the exception. Researchers estimate that 90 to 95 percent of federal and state cases end in plea bargains.12Bureau of Justice Assistance. Plea and Charge Bargaining Research Summary The defendant pleads guilty, usually to a reduced charge or with a lighter sentencing recommendation, and the government avoids the cost and uncertainty of trial.
Plea agreements have to be disclosed in open court. The judge must confirm the defendant understands the rights being waived, including the right to a jury trial, to confront witnesses, and to remain silent. The judge also checks that the plea is voluntary and not driven by threats or outside promises. Judges can reject plea deals, though they rarely do. When the agreement involves the government dropping other charges, courts tend to defer to the prosecutor’s judgment without being required to approve it automatically.8Congress.gov. Federal Prosecutorial Discretion – A Brief Overview
What the Government Has to Share
Prosecutors have a constitutional duty to disclose evidence that helps the defense. Under Brady v. Maryland, the government must turn over any evidence favorable to the defendant that is material to guilt or punishment. The duty applies whether or not the defense asks, and whether the suppression was intentional or accidental.13Library of Congress. Brady v Maryland, 373 US 83
The Supreme Court extended this in Giglio v. United States to information affecting the credibility of government witnesses. If a witness was promised leniency in exchange for testimony, the jury has a right to know.14Justia U.S. Supreme Court Center. Giglio v United States The obligation is institutional. One prosecutor’s promise binds the whole office, and ignorance of what another attorney knew isn’t a defense.
Brady violations are a common ground for overturning convictions on appeal. To win reversal, a defendant has to show a reasonable probability that the outcome would have been different had the evidence been disclosed. The cases that succeed usually involve meaningful omissions: undisclosed deals with cooperating witnesses, suppressed forensic results, or hidden evidence pointing to someone else.
What Happens at Trial
If the case doesn’t resolve, it goes to trial. The sequence runs in a predictable order.
Jury Selection
Both sides help choose the jury through voir dire. The lawyers question potential jurors about biases, relationships to the case, or anything else that might affect impartiality. Jurors can be removed “for cause” when there’s a specific reason they can’t be fair, with no cap on those challenges. Each side also gets a fixed number of peremptory challenges, which allow striking a juror without stating a reason. Peremptory challenges can’t be used to exclude jurors based on race or sex.
Opening Statements and Evidence
The prosecution opens first because it carries the burden of proof. An opening statement previews the evidence and the theory of the case without crossing into argument. The prosecutor then calls witnesses and introduces exhibits, using direct examination to draw out facts from people with firsthand knowledge. Every piece of evidence has to clear the rules of evidence before the jury can consider it.
After each prosecution witness, the defense cross-examines, testing memory, perception, bias, or honesty. When the defense puts on its own case, the prosecutor cross-examines in turn. After both sides rest, the prosecutor can offer limited rebuttal evidence addressing points the defense raised.
Closing Arguments
In closing, the prosecutor connects testimony and exhibits to the legal elements of each charge and argues that, taken together, the evidence proves guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The defense then gives its closing, and the prosecution usually gets a brief rebuttal, a procedural reflection of the government’s heavier burden.
The Burden of Proof
The government must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, the highest standard in American law. In In re Winship, the Supreme Court held that the Due Process Clause “protects the accused against conviction except upon proof beyond a reasonable doubt of every fact necessary to constitute the crime with which he is charged.”15Legal Information Institute. In the Matter of Samuel Winship, Appellant Every element has to meet this standard, not just the overall picture.
The burden never shifts. The defendant doesn’t have to testify, call witnesses, or produce any evidence. If the prosecution’s case leaves the jury with a reasonable doubt on any essential element, the jury must acquit.
Double Jeopardy
The Fifth Amendment provides that no person shall “be subject for the same offense to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb.”3Legal Information Institute. Fifth Amendment If a defendant is acquitted, the government cannot retry the same crime even if new evidence surfaces. Jeopardy attaches at a defined moment: in a jury trial, when the jury is sworn; in a bench trial, when the first witness is sworn in.
The protection has limits. A mistrial declared at the defendant’s request usually doesn’t bar retrial. And because federal and state governments are separate sovereigns, a federal acquittal doesn’t block state charges for the same conduct, or the reverse. That exception is narrow but real, and it’s why some defendants face parallel prosecutions.
Sentencing
If the case ends in a guilty verdict or plea, the prosecutor’s work continues. In federal court, both sides make arguments about where the defendant falls within the federal sentencing guidelines, which produce a recommended range based on offense severity and criminal history.16United States Sentencing Commission. An Overview of the Federal Sentencing Guidelines The prosecutor can file motions that shape the calculation, recommend a specific sentence, argue for an upward departure based on aggravating factors, or oppose a defense request for leniency. The guidelines have been advisory rather than mandatory since the Supreme Court’s 2005 decision in United States v. Booker, but they remain the starting point for virtually every federal sentence. The judge decides, and the prosecutor’s position carries weight, especially because the government often controls much of the factual record that drives the guideline calculation.