Depositions are a routine part of civil litigation, but in criminal cases they are the exception. Only four states — Florida, Missouri, Iowa, and North Dakota — allow depositions in criminal cases as a broad discovery tool. A smaller group, including New Hampshire, Texas, Arizona, Vermont, Indiana, and Nebraska, permits them under narrower circumstances that usually require a judge’s approval. Everywhere else, including in federal court, criminal depositions exist almost exclusively to preserve the testimony of a witness who will likely be unavailable at trial.
Two Different Things Called a Deposition
The reason the state-by-state answer varies so much is that “criminal deposition” covers two very different procedures.
A discovery deposition is what most people picture: a lawyer questions a witness before trial to find out what they know, test their credibility, and prepare cross-examination. This is standard in civil cases. In criminal cases, only a handful of states permit it.
A preservation deposition is narrower. Its purpose is to lock in testimony from a witness who may not make it to trial — an elderly victim in failing health, for example, or a witness about to leave the country. Nearly every state and the federal system allow preservation depositions, but only after a judge is convinced the witness is genuinely at risk of being unavailable and the testimony is material.
The gap matters for defendants. In states that permit only preservation depositions, defense attorneys usually hear the prosecution’s witnesses testify under cross-examination for the first time at trial itself.
States That Allow Broad Criminal Discovery Depositions
Four states treat criminal depositions more like their civil counterparts.
Florida. After charges are filed, either party may depose any person by oral examination in felony cases. Misdemeanor cases require a showing of good cause. Florida has special protections for witnesses under sixteen and for witnesses the court deems emotionally fragile; those depositions must be taken before a judge or special master and recorded on video.
Missouri. A defendant in any criminal case may depose any person after an indictment or information is filed, and the depositions follow civil procedure rules. The defendant is generally not physically present unless the parties agree or the court finds good cause.
Iowa. A defendant may depose all witnesses listed by the state in the minutes of testimony. In exchange, Iowa requires reciprocal disclosure: the defendant must provide a list of defense witnesses before or at the time of depositions, and the state may then depose anyone on that list. Depositions must be taken within 30 days of arraignment unless the defendant waives speedy trial rights. The defendant must be personally present at all depositions, with narrow exceptions when identity is at issue.
North Dakota. After the defendant appears, any party may depose any person. North Dakota explicitly separates discovery depositions, which are broadly available, from depositions to perpetuate testimony, which require leave of court. The court can limit or shut down any deposition that would unreasonably harass or burden a witness.
These four states share a philosophy that broader pretrial discovery produces fairer outcomes and fewer surprises at trial. Florida’s system has been cited by defense reform advocates as a model, though prosecutors there have argued it imposes burdens on witnesses and slows cases down.
States That Allow Depositions on a Narrower Showing
Several states permit criminal depositions but place meaningful conditions on them. The common thread is judicial gatekeeping: a judge has to find that the deposition serves a specific purpose before it goes forward.
New Hampshire. The court may permit a deposition upon a finding of necessity, either to preserve testimony or to ensure a fair trial and avoid surprise. In felony cases, either party has an independent right to depose the other side’s expert witnesses without needing court permission. No party may depose a victim or witness under sixteen.
Texas. Either the state or the defendant may take depositions, but the requesting party must file an affidavit showing good reason. A judge holds a hearing and decides whether to allow it.
Arizona. Depositions are available only in specific situations: when a witness is likely unavailable and their testimony is material, when a witness was not examined at a preliminary hearing and refuses to cooperate with a personal interview, or when a witness is incarcerated for failing to post bond. Arizona also gives victims the right to refuse a deposition requested by the defense.
Vermont, Indiana, and Nebraska. These states allow some form of criminal depositions, with scope and procedures that vary by jurisdiction.
In each of these states, the requesting party carries the burden of justifying the deposition, and most motions turn on whether the attorney can convince the judge that the deposition is genuinely necessary rather than a fishing expedition.
Federal Criminal Cases: Rule 15
Federal practice is the most restrictive. Under Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 15, depositions are available only to preserve testimony, never for general discovery. The moving party must show “exceptional circumstances” and that the deposition serves “the interest of justice.”1Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 15 – Depositions Courts enforce that bar strictly.
A party may only move to depose its own witnesses, not the opposing party’s. A defendant cannot be deposed without consent. The scope of questioning must mirror what would be allowed at trial, so the deposition functions as a dry run of trial testimony rather than open-ended investigation. Either side may use all or part of the deposition at trial as permitted by the Federal Rules of Evidence.1Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 15 – Depositions
When the witness is outside the United States, Rule 15 adds a further requirement: the court must find on the specific facts that the testimony “could provide substantial proof of a material fact” in a felony prosecution.1Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 15 – Depositions This comes up most often in international fraud and drug trafficking cases.
In practice, depositions in federal criminal cases are rare. The federal system relies on other discovery mechanisms, including witness statements, grand jury transcripts, and mandatory disclosures under the Brady and Jencks rules.
Constitutional Limits on Using Deposition Testimony
Whatever state allows a deposition, the Sixth Amendment governs how the resulting transcript can be used at trial. The Confrontation Clause guarantees defendants the right “to be confronted with the witnesses against” them.2Constitution Annotated. Right to Confront Witnesses Face-to-Face
In Crawford v. Washington (2004), the Supreme Court held that testimonial statements from a witness who does not appear at trial are inadmissible unless the witness is unavailable and the defendant had a prior opportunity to cross-examine.3Legal Information Institute. Crawford v Washington A deposition where defense counsel conducted a full cross-examination satisfies the second requirement; a police interview without defense counsel does not. Courts look closely at whether the cross was genuinely adversarial and whether the defense had adequate preparation. A rushed deposition where the defense had no discovery yet may not pass.
And in Barber v. Page (1968), the Court established that a witness is not “unavailable” unless the prosecution made a good-faith effort to bring them to trial.4Justia. Barber v Page, 390 US 719 (1968) The state cannot take a deposition, let the witness drift away, and then substitute the transcript for live testimony.
The upshot: deposition testimony is a backup, not a shortcut. Live testimony subject to in-court cross remains the constitutional default.
What Actually Determines Whether a Deposition Happens
Even in states that allow criminal depositions, several practical factors shape whether one gets taken.
Cost. Court reporters charge per-page rates for certified transcripts, and a full deposition can run hundreds of dollars. Expert witness depositions add another layer: in Missouri and other states, the party taking the deposition pays the expert a reasonable hourly fee for the time spent being deposed. For defendants with appointed counsel, funding depends on the jurisdiction’s public defense system. Some states let appointed attorneys seek reimbursement for deposition expenses, but the process is not automatic.
Defendant’s presence. Rules differ sharply. Iowa requires the defendant to be present. Missouri generally excludes the defendant unless the court finds good cause. Arizona grants defendants the right to attend certain depositions but not others. In federal cases, the defendant cannot be deposed without consent.
Witness protections. Courts frequently impose conditions, including limits on duration, video rather than in-person appearance, and in Arizona, a victim’s right to refuse the deposition altogether.
Denials. Courts deny criminal deposition requests regularly. The most common reasons are failure to show materiality, concerns about harassment or intimidation, and unreasonable delay. Judges who believe the information can be obtained through less intrusive means often steer parties toward written interrogatories or stipulations instead.
A deposition that was improperly taken or conducted outside the rules can be excluded from evidence entirely. That is the risk that keeps criminal attorneys cautious: a sloppy deposition can be worse than none at all, because it may telegraph the defense strategy without producing any usable testimony.