If someone is threatening to expose you, stop responding, save every message, and report the threat to local police and the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center. The threat itself is already a crime under federal law in most circumstances, and you have both criminal and civil options. What you do in the first day matters most: paying, deleting, or arguing all make the situation worse.
The First 24 Hours
Three instincts will hurt you. Paying confirms you’ll cooperate and almost always leads to more demands. Deleting the messages destroys the evidence you need. Negotiating signals you’ll play along and turns you into a long-term target.
Do this instead:
- Stop replying. No counteroffers, no further payments, no additional images. Silence is your strongest immediate move.
- Preserve everything. Save emails, texts, voicemails, direct messages, and social media interactions. Screenshot the full thread with timestamps and usernames visible.
- Think honestly about the potential fallout — career, relationships, safety. That assessment helps you prioritize and lets you communicate clearly with an attorney or officer.
- Report it. File with the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center if any part of the threat came through a digital channel, and contact local police to start a formal record.
Cutting off contact and preserving evidence are the two moves that matter most right now. The rest of what follows builds on them.
How to Document the Threats
A case against the person threatening you lives or dies on evidence. What you capture now becomes the basis for criminal charges, a civil suit, or a protective order.
- Keep the originals, not just screenshots. Preserve the actual emails, texts, and direct messages in their native format. Screenshots can be challenged as manipulated; original files carry metadata that proves authenticity.
- Note dates, times, and context for every communication — platform, what was happening in your life at the time, how the messages escalated. A pattern is far more compelling than one isolated threat.
- Capture usernames, profile URLs, phone numbers, and anything else identifying. Accounts often disappear once the person realizes the situation is getting serious.
- Save confirmations when you report abuse to a social media company or email provider. These show you took reasonable steps to limit harm.
One warning about recording phone calls. Most states follow one-party consent rules, so you can record a call you’re part of without telling the other person. A smaller group of states requires everyone on the line to consent. In an all-party state, a secret recording may be inadmissible and could expose you to liability. Check your state’s rule before you hit record.
Reporting to Law Enforcement
Once you have documentation, bring it in. Start with your local police department and file a formal report. Printed copies of messages, screenshots, call logs, and a written timeline get taken more seriously than a verbal account.
If the threat crossed state lines or came through any online channel, also file with the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center. The intake form asks for your contact information, how you were victimized, and details about any payments you made.1Internet Crime Complaint Center. Internet Crime Complaint Center You can file whether you or the person threatening you is in the United States.
Set realistic expectations. Investigations move slowly, especially when they involve digital forensics or multiple jurisdictions. Stay in touch with the officer or agent on your case, follow up, and keep preserving any new messages. A criminal investigation does not stop you from pursuing a protective order or a civil lawsuit at the same time.
The Threat Itself Is Already a Crime
You do not have to wait for the person to carry out the threat. Several federal statutes criminalize the demand on its own.
The one that applies most often is 18 U.S.C. § 875(d). Sending a communication across state lines — by phone, text, email, social media, or any digital platform — that threatens to damage someone’s reputation or accuse them of a crime in order to extort money or anything of value carries up to two years in federal prison. Because almost every modern threat travels through interstate networks, the statute covers the vast majority of online and phone-based cases. If the demand includes a threat to injure someone, the penalty rises to 20 years.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 875 – Interstate Communications
If the person got the information by hacking an account or stealing files from your devices, the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act adds another layer. The CFAA makes it a federal crime to access a computer without authorization or to exceed authorized access to obtain information, with penalties that climb based on the circumstances.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 18 USC 1030 – Fraud and Related Activity in Connection With Computers Someone who hacked your email to grab compromising photos and then threatened to release them can be charged under both the CFAA and the extortion statute.
State extortion and blackmail laws sit alongside these federal statutes and often carry significant penalties of their own. Which charges are available depends on where the conduct occurred.
If the Threat Involves Intimate Images
Threats to share intimate photos or videos have their own dedicated law. The TAKE IT DOWN Act, signed in May 2025, created the first federal criminal penalty for publishing non-consensual intimate images of adults, with up to two years in prison.4Congress.gov. The TAKE IT DOWN Act – A Federal Law Prohibiting Non-Consensual Intimate Imagery
The critical point for anyone being threatened right now: the Act criminalizes the threat to distribute, not just the actual distribution, and carries the same penalties either way. Someone who threatens to post your intimate images has already committed a federal crime, even if they never follow through. The law also covers AI-generated or digitally altered intimate images, with penalties of up to 18 months for adults and 30 months for minors. Penalties rise to three years when the images are of someone under 18.4Congress.gov. The TAKE IT DOWN Act – A Federal Law Prohibiting Non-Consensual Intimate Imagery All 50 states also have their own criminal laws against distributing intimate images without consent.
Getting a Protective Order
If you need immediate legal protection, a protective order — sometimes called a restraining order — can prohibit the person from contacting you, approaching you, or continuing the threats. Violating the order is itself a separate criminal offense, which gives police a quick way to intervene.
When the situation is urgent, courts can issue emergency orders (called ex parte orders) without the other person present. These take effect immediately and last for a limited period, often around 14 days, until a full hearing. At that hearing the judge decides whether to extend the order or make it permanent.
You file by submitting a petition to your local court with evidence of the threats. Many states waive filing fees entirely for protective orders related to harassment, stalking, or domestic violence. If you can’t afford an attorney, legal aid organizations can help you prepare the petition.
Suing for Damages
Criminal prosecution punishes the person; a civil lawsuit compensates you. The two run in parallel. You don’t need to wait for criminal charges before suing.
The claim that fits exposure threats most directly is public disclosure of private facts. To win, you have to show that the person gave wide publicity to information about your private life, that a reasonable person would find the disclosure highly offensive, and that the information isn’t a matter of legitimate public concern. Sexually explicit disclosures routinely clear the offensiveness bar, and other kinds of private information — financial records, medical conditions, family matters — can qualify depending on the context.
Related privacy claims cover different angles. Intrusion upon seclusion applies when the person invaded your private space to get the information in the first place, such as by hacking your phone. Appropriation of name or likeness applies if someone used your identity for their own benefit. False light claims address publicizing misleading information that portrays you in a distorted way.
If what the person threatens to reveal is false, you may also have a defamation claim. Defamation requires a false statement, communicated to someone other than you, that damages your reputation. Truth is a complete defense, so if the threatened information is accurate, defamation won’t apply, though a privacy claim still might. Public figures must prove the person knew the statement was false or acted with reckless disregard for the truth; private individuals generally only need to show negligence, though the standard varies by jurisdiction.
You can also seek compensation for the emotional toll — anxiety, depression, lost sleep, the fear of exposure — along with lost income if the threats forced you to miss work or harmed your professional reputation. Courts can award compensatory damages for actual losses and, in egregious cases, punitive damages aimed at punishing outrageous conduct.
Keeping Your Name Out of the Court Record
One fear that stops victims from suing is that the lawsuit will expose what the person was threatening to reveal in the first place. Courts normally require plaintiffs to use their real names, but a judge can allow you to proceed as “Jane Doe” or “John Doe” when privacy interests are strong enough.
You request permission before filing, and the court weighs your privacy interest against the public’s right to open proceedings. Factors that favor anonymity include cases involving intimate or sexual information, situations where filing could expose you to criminal prosecution, and cases involving minors. Even when a judge denies the request, the court may still issue protective orders limiting public access to sensitive filings. Courts regularly grant pseudonym requests in cases involving threatened exposure of intimate images or deeply private information. An attorney experienced in privacy litigation can assess your odds and handle the motion.