What Voting Rights Are Under Attack: ID Rules, Purges, and Courts

Voting rights in the United States are under attack on three fronts at once: state legislatures are passing laws that make registering and casting a ballot harder, the Supreme Court has steadily dismantled the federal Voting Rights Act, and Congress has not restored what the Court took away. The practical consequence is that whether you can vote, and how easily, now depends heavily on which state you live in, what identification you carry, where you receive mail, and whether you have a felony conviction in your past.

Here is what has actually changed, who is most affected, and what protections remain.

What’s Changing at the Polling Place

In 2025, at least 16 states enacted 29 restrictive voting laws, according to the Brennan Center for Justice. It was the first year since 2020 that restrictive laws outpaced laws expanding access.1Brennan Center for Justice. State Voting Laws Roundup The Voting Rights Lab found restrictive laws increased by 50 percent in the first half of 2025 compared with the same period in 2024, and only one in three new election laws improved access.2Voting Rights Lab. 2025 Legislative Sessions to Date: Key Election Policy Trends The pattern continued into 2026.

Narrower ID Rules

As of April 2025, 36 states require voters to show some form of identification at the polls, and the list of acceptable documents keeps shrinking.3National Conference of State Legislatures. Voter ID In 2025, Kentucky, Montana, and West Virginia eliminated non-photo ID options, and Indiana banned student IDs for voting.2Voting Rights Lab. 2025 Legislative Sessions to Date: Key Election Policy Trends In 2026, Florida removed debit cards, student IDs, retirement center IDs, and public assistance IDs from its accepted list, and New Hampshire also dropped student IDs.4Brennan Center for Justice. State Voting Laws Roundup, May 2026

Research matching voter rolls against driver’s license databases has found that strict photo ID laws disproportionately affect racial minority voters in states including North Carolina, Texas, and Wisconsin.5MIT Election Data + Science Lab. Voter Identification

Kansas added an unusual twist. SB 244, enacted in 2026, invalidates driver’s licenses showing a gender marker different from the holder’s sex assigned at birth. Because Kansas has required photo ID to vote since 2012, the law effectively threatens to strip transgender residents of their primary voter ID. The ACLU is challenging the law in Doe v. State of Kansas.6ACLU. Doe v. State of Kansas

Proof-of-Citizenship to Register

A growing group of states now requires documentary proof of citizenship, such as a birth certificate or passport, to register. Indiana and Wyoming enacted such laws in 2025.7Brennan Center for Justice. State Voting Laws Roundup, October 2025 In 2026, Florida passed a law directing officials to verify citizenship through motor vehicle records beginning in 2027; voters whose citizenship cannot be confirmed will have to present a passport or birth certificate. The Florida law also requires proof of a legal name change where the name on citizenship documents differs from a voter’s current ID, a requirement critics say burdens married women who changed their names.4Brennan Center for Justice. State Voting Laws Roundup, May 2026

The federal SAVE Act, which would require in-person documentary proof of citizenship to register for federal elections, passed the House in February 2026 but has stalled in the Senate.8League of Women Voters. Five Major Legislative Issues in 2025 and Their Impact on 2026 The Brennan Center estimates that 21 million American citizens lack ready access to the required documentation.9Brennan Center for Justice. States Already Enacting Harmful SAVE Act Policies Requiring Proof of Citizenship

Mail Voting and Drop Boxes

At least 19 states have introduced new restrictions on mail voting since the 2020 election.10Brennan Center for Justice. State-by-State Guide to Restrictive Changes to Voter ID, Mail Voting, and Ballot Collection In 2025, Kansas and North Dakota eliminated grace periods for ballots postmarked by Election Day but arriving afterward. Arkansas began requiring mail voters to complete an additional affidavit in front of a witness.7Brennan Center for Justice. State Voting Laws Roundup, October 2025 Utah enacted a law that will end universal mail voting by 2029, requiring voters to opt in rather than automatically receiving a ballot.2Voting Rights Lab. 2025 Legislative Sessions to Date: Key Election Policy Trends

Drop boxes have shrunk too. Georgia’s 2021 law restricted them to one per 100,000 voters or one per early voting site and ended 24-hour access. Texas banned them. Florida required them to be staffed and located at early voting sites, limiting availability to business hours. The Wisconsin Supreme Court ruled in 2022 that drop boxes were illegal under state law.11Center for Public Integrity. Campaign to Stamp Out Ballot Drop Boxes

Getting Purged From the Rolls

Even registered voters can lose their status without warning. Between 2020 and 2022, over 19 million voters were removed from voter rolls nationwide, a 21 percent increase from the 2014–2016 period.12Brennan Center for Justice. Voter Purges

Ohio’s SB 293 mandates monthly citizenship checks using the federal SAVE database and state motor vehicle records. The League of Women Voters of Ohio and others sued in February 2026, alleging the law violates the National Voter Registration Act’s ban on systematic purges within 90 days of a federal election and its requirement that list maintenance be uniform and nondiscriminatory.13Campaign Legal Center. League of Women Voters of Ohio v. LaRose Texas faces a similar lawsuit, with challengers arguing the state relies on “faulty and outdated” data without adequate verification.14Campaign Legal Center. Inside the Effort to Purge Eligible Voters Ahead of 2026 Midterms Alabama flagged 2,074 voters as noncitizens before the November 2024 election, and reports indicated eligible citizens were swept up. Virginia conducted a similar pre-election purge that also removed eligible voters.15Votebeat. Election Security vs. Voting Rights: Voter Roll List Maintenance

Eight states have also withdrawn from the Electronic Registration Information Center (ERIC), a multistate data-sharing system that helped identify voters who had moved, died, or registered in multiple states. Replacement arrangements have been patchy and, according to election officials, less reliable.16American Oversight. The Scramble to Replace ERIC: How States That Left Nonpartisan System Have Fallen Short

The practical takeaway: check your registration status before every election, especially if your state has adopted citizenship-verification rules or left ERIC.

Why Federal Protection Is Weaker Than It Was

The Voting Rights Act of 1965 was once the strongest federal tool against racial discrimination in elections. Three Supreme Court decisions over 13 years have left it a shell.

Shelby County v. Holder (2013)

The Court struck down the formula that determined which states and localities with histories of racial discrimination had to get federal approval before changing voting rules. That effectively ended the Section 5 preclearance process. On the day of the ruling, Texas announced it would implement a voter ID law that preclearance had previously blocked; a court later found that law racially discriminatory. North Carolina enacted what a federal court called a law targeting Black voters “with almost surgical precision.” Between 2012 and 2018, counties previously subject to preclearance closed at least 1,688 polling places.17NAACP Legal Defense Fund. Shelby County v. Holder Impact

Brnovich v. Democratic National Committee (2021)

With preclearance gone, Section 2 of the VRA became the primary tool for challenging discriminatory laws in court. In July 2021, the Supreme Court made Section 2 significantly harder to use. Upholding two Arizona policies that discarded out-of-precinct ballots and criminalized third-party ballot collection, the Court set new “guideposts” requiring plaintiffs to show more than a “modest” burden, that a law departs from standard practices as they existed in 1982, and that statistical disparities are large enough to matter. State interests like fraud prevention weigh in favor of upholding restrictions.18Supreme Court of the United States. Brnovich v. Democratic National Committee, 594 U.S. ___ (2021) Justice Kagan, in dissent, wrote that the majority had “rewritten — in order to weaken — a statute that stands as a monument to America’s greatness.”19Harvard Law Review. Brnovich v. Democratic National Committee

Louisiana v. Callais (2026)

On April 29, 2026, the Court decided Louisiana v. Callais by a 6-3 vote. Louisiana had redrawn its congressional map to include a second majority-Black district after a lower court found the original map likely violated Section 2. The Supreme Court struck the new map down as an unconstitutional racial gerrymander and held that Section 2 did not actually require the additional district.20SCOTUSblog. Court Decides Major Voting Rights Act Case

The ruling rewrote Section 2 redistricting standards. It held that Section 2 “imposes liability only when the evidence supports a strong inference that the State intentionally drew its districts to afford minority voters less opportunity because of their race.” Proving intentional discrimination is, as legal experts have noted, “notoriously difficult.”21NPR. Supreme Court Voting Rights Act State Local Redistricting The decision also required plaintiffs to control for partisan affiliation when demonstrating racially polarized voting and restricted the weight courts can give to historical evidence of discrimination.22Supreme Court of the United States. Louisiana v. Callais, 608 U.S. ___ (2026) Justice Kagan, in dissent, called the ruling the “completed demolition of the Voting Rights Act” and said Section 2 was “all but a dead letter.”20SCOTUSblog. Court Decides Major Voting Rights Act Case

Does Your Vote Still Count the Same? Redistricting After Callais

Since the Supreme Court held in Rucho v. Common Cause (2019) that federal courts cannot police partisan gerrymandering, both parties have redrawn maps aggressively. Texas touched off the current cycle in 2025 when Governor Greg Abbott directed the legislature to redraw the congressional map mid-decade. The new map was designed to deliver Republican victories in up to 30 of 38 districts. A three-judge federal court blocked it in November 2025, finding “substantial evidence” of racial gerrymandering, but the Supreme Court reversed in December 2025, allowing Texas to use the map in 2026.23SCOTUSblog. Supreme Court Allows Texas to Use Redistricting Map Challenged as Racially Discriminatory

California suspended its independent redistricting commission to draw a map adding Democratic seats. Florida passed a map aiming to cut its Democratic delegation in half. Virginia drew new lines expected to eliminate all but one Republican seat. More than 25 percent of all U.S. congressional seats have been redrawn mid-decade during this period.24Harvard Kennedy School. Explainer: What’s Happening With Gerrymandering in the United States After Callais, several states, including Alabama, Tennessee, and Mississippi, have considered special sessions to eliminate majority-minority districts, with experts projecting five or more such districts could be dismantled before the 2026 elections.

Who Faces the Steepest Barriers

Native American Voters

Native Americans face barriers rooted in geography, infrastructure, and ID rules. Many reservations lack standard residential addresses, which breaks registration systems built around street addresses. Mail service on tribal lands is often unreliable, with post offices located 20 to 40 miles from voters’ homes and limited operating hours.25National Conference of State Legislatures. Voting for All Americans: Native Americans From 2012 to 2022, voter turnout on tribal lands averaged 11 percentage points lower than in surrounding areas, and voters on tribal lands were seven percentage points less likely to vote by mail or vote early.26Brennan Center for Justice. Voting on Tribal Lands

Tribal ID cards are not universally accepted. Some states have moved to fix this. Colorado accepts Bureau of Indian Affairs and Indian Health Service cards, even without photos. New Mexico requires counties to establish polling places on tribal land on request and prohibits eliminating existing ones. Nevada mandates polling places and drop boxes on tribal lands unless a tribe opts out.25National Conference of State Legislatures. Voting for All Americans: Native Americans The proposed federal Native American Voting Rights Act has not advanced.

Voters With Disabilities

About 40.2 million eligible voters have disabilities.27U.S. Election Assistance Commission. Voting Accessibility Polling place accessibility has improved, but gaps remain. In Alabama, an Election Protection Coalition survey in 2024 documented polling sites with broken ramps, doors requiring excessive force, hazardous mold, and inadequate lighting.28ACLU. Accessible Voting Is Under Attack 35 Years After the ADA Alabama’s SB 1, signed in 2024, makes it a criminal offense punishable by up to 20 years in prison to assist a voter with requesting, filling out, or delivering an absentee ballot application. Disability rights advocates say the law threatens the independence of voters who rely on caregiver assistance.

People With Felony Convictions

Whether you can vote after a conviction depends almost entirely on your state. Maine, Vermont, and the District of Columbia never revoke voting rights, even during incarceration. Twenty-three states automatically restore rights upon release from prison. Ten states, including Alabama, Florida, Iowa, Kentucky, Mississippi, and Virginia, impose indefinite loss of voting rights or require a governor’s pardon or additional judicial action for restoration.29National Conference of State Legislatures. Felon Voting Rights Up to 19 million Americans with past felony convictions are currently eligible to vote but may not know it, given the complexity of restoration rules.30Campaign Legal Center. Restore Your Vote

Recent changes have cut both ways. Nebraska restored voting rights upon sentence completion in 2024. Minnesota and New Mexico extended rights to people on parole in 2023. Tennessee revised its restoration procedures in 2025. Virginia’s governor, however, reinstated a requirement for individualized applications, reversing an earlier policy of broader automatic restoration.29National Conference of State Legislatures. Felon Voting Rights

Where Protection Still Exists

Federal fixes have gone nowhere. The John R. Lewis Voting Rights Advancement Act, which would reinstate a modernized preclearance process, was reintroduced in March 2025 with every House Democrat as a sponsor but faces unified Republican opposition.31Office of Representative Terri Sewell. Rep. Sewell Introduces the John R. Lewis Voting Rights Advancement Act The Freedom to Vote Act, which would set national standards for voter access, has also not advanced.

Ten states have passed their own voting rights acts: California, Colorado, Connecticut, Illinois, Maryland, Minnesota, New York, Oregon, Virginia, and Washington. Maryland became the most recent in April 2026 with SB 255, which targets racial vote dilution at the local level and lets the attorney general or individual residents challenge discriminatory voting plans.32Maryland Matters. Voting Rights Act for Maryland Stirred Emotions Well Before Monday Meltdown Lawmakers in at least nine more states introduced similar bills in 2026.33Stateline. States Step Into Voting Rights Void Left by Federal Rulings

These state laws generally prohibit vote dilution, require local preclearance for changes to election procedures, and create private rights of action. One important limit: they apply to local and county governments rather than congressional districts, so they do not reach the mid-decade congressional maps now being drawn.34National Conference of State Legislatures. State Voting Rights Acts Whether state-level protections can meaningfully substitute for a functioning federal Voting Rights Act, especially after Louisiana v. Callais, remains an open question.