A legal claim accrues at the moment every element needed to sue and win exists at once — the wrongful act, the causation, and the harm. That date, not the date you decide to file, is what starts the statute of limitations running. The Supreme Court describes it as the point when “the plaintiff can file suit and obtain relief.”1Justia Law. Wallace v. Kato, 549 U.S. 384 (2007) Pinpointing that date is often harder than it sounds, and getting it wrong by a day can permanently end an otherwise strong case.
The Default: Accrual Happens When the Harm Happens
For most claims, accrual is tied to a single event. In a car crash, the claim accrues at the moment of the collision, because negligence, causation, and injury all arrive together. Vandalism to your car accrues the day it happens. A defective ladder that breaks under you accrues at the fall. There is no waiting period and nothing ambiguous about the timing.
This event-based approach governs most personal injury suits, property damage claims, and straightforward torts. The injury and its cause are obvious, so nothing delays the clock.
Contract Claims Can Have More Than One Accrual Date
A basic contract claim accrues when one side fails to do what the agreement required. A contractor who blows a completion deadline breaches on that date. But contracts introduce two situations the default rule does not quite handle.
Installment Contracts
When a contract calls for periodic payments or deliveries, each missed installment is treated as its own breach with its own accrual date. If a borrower stops paying a loan in January and the limitations period is four years, the January claim expires four years from January, the February claim four years from February, and so on. Some missed payments may be time-barred while later ones remain actionable. The debt is not simply “live” or “dead” as a whole.
Anticipatory Repudiation
If a party announces in advance that they will not perform, you do not have to wait for the performance date to arrive. The claim accrues when the repudiation is clear and unequivocal. A supplier who tells you in March that no June delivery is coming has given you an immediate right to sue, and sitting on that right eats into your limitations period.
The Discovery Rule: When the Injury Was Hidden
The event-based rule works when the harm is obvious. Plenty of injuries are not. A surgical instrument left inside a patient, a foundation cracking behind the drywall, a financial advisor quietly draining an account — in each situation, starting the clock at the moment of the wrongful act would punish people for not knowing something they had no way of knowing.
The discovery rule delays accrual until the injured person discovers, or reasonably should have discovered, both the injury and its likely cause. The standard is reasonableness, not actual knowledge. If a routine medical follow-up or a standard home inspection would have revealed the problem, a court may decide you should have known sooner. The clock starts when a reasonable person in your position would have connected the dots.
The discovery rule is not automatic, though. In Rotkiske v. Klemm, the Supreme Court held that when a statute uses a clear event-based trigger, courts should not graft a discovery rule on top of it unless the statute itself includes one.2Supreme Court of the United States. Rotkiske v. Klemm, 589 U.S. 8 (2019) In Gabelli v. SEC, the Court refused to extend the rule to a federal fraud enforcement action, reasoning that the rule exists to protect victims who have no reason to suspect wrongdoing, not agencies whose job is to investigate it.3Justia Law. Gabelli v. SEC, 568 U.S. 442 (2013) Whether the rule saves your claim depends on the statute and the jurisdiction.
Continuing Violations: One Clock or Many?
Some wrongful conduct is a pattern rather than an event. Workplace harassment, ongoing environmental contamination, and repeated discriminatory acts all raise the same problem: when does the clock start if the harm never really stops?
The Supreme Court drew the line in National Railroad Passenger Corp. v. Morgan. Discrete acts, like a firing or a denied promotion, each trigger their own filing deadline. Miss the window on one, and it is time-barred even if later related acts remain timely. A hostile work environment claim is different. Because harassment is by nature a pattern, the whole course of conduct remains actionable so long as at least one contributing act falls within the filing period.4Justia Law. National Railroad Passenger Corp. v. Morgan, 536 U.S. 101 (2002)
The same question comes up with repeated trespass, serial pollution, and ongoing breaches of duty. The answer turns on whether the court sees the conduct as a series of independent wrongs or a single unlawful practice unfolding over time.
When the Clock Pauses
Even after a claim accrues, certain circumstances can pause the limitations period. This is called tolling.
Minors and Incapacitated Persons
Most jurisdictions pause the clock for people who lack the legal capacity to sue on their own. If a child is injured, the limitations period typically does not begin running until the child reaches the age of majority. If a person is mentally incapacitated when the claim accrues, the clock usually waits until they regain capacity or a legal representative is appointed. Federal law follows this approach in environmental exposure cases, where the limitations period for minors does not start until they turn eighteen or get a legal representative.5Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 42 USC 9658 – Actions Under State Law for Damages From Exposure to Hazardous Substances
Fraudulent Concealment
When a defendant actively hides wrongdoing, courts may toll the statute until the plaintiff discovers or should have discovered the concealment. This goes beyond the ordinary discovery rule. Fraudulent concealment requires affirmative steps to prevent you from learning about the claim — falsified records, lies about what happened, deliberate silence where there was a duty to disclose. Your own ignorance of easily discoverable facts is not enough. The defendant must have done something to keep you in the dark.
Equitable Tolling
Courts occasionally toll the clock when a plaintiff pursued their rights diligently but extraordinary circumstances prevented timely filing. A court clerk misfiles paperwork. A defendant gives misleading information about the deadline. Equitable tolling is granted sparingly and generally requires both reasonable diligence on your part and something beyond your control that blocked a timely filing. The Supreme Court has confirmed equitable tolling applies to statutes of limitations, but not to statutes of repose.6Legal Information Institute. CTS Corp. v. Waldburger, 573 U.S. 1 (2014)
Statutes of Repose Can Kill a Claim Before It Accrues
A statute of repose works like a hard expiration date, and it operates on different logic than the accrual rules above. Instead of running from the date your claim accrues, it runs from a specific event with nothing to do with your injury — the date a building was substantially completed, the date a product was first sold. When the repose period ends, the right to sue is gone, even if you have not yet been hurt.
The Supreme Court put it directly: a statute of repose is “not related to the accrual of any cause of action; the injury need not have occurred, much less have been discovered.” And a statute of repose cannot be tolled. No discovery rule, no equitable exception, no pause for minors or incapacity.6Legal Information Institute. CTS Corp. v. Waldburger, 573 U.S. 1 (2014)
Every state has at least one. Construction defects are the most common target, with deadlines typically running six to twenty years after substantial completion. About half the states also apply repose periods to product liability claims, and some extend them to medical malpractice. A homeowner who discovers a structural defect in year eight of a ten-year repose period has two years to file, regardless of the ordinary limitations clock. The same defect surfacing in year eleven produces a claim that is dead on arrival.
Government Claims Run on a Much Shorter Clock
Claims against government entities follow a separate timeline, and this is where people most often lose cases they should have won. Both federal and state governments impose short administrative notice requirements that must be met before you can file suit.
Federal Claims
Under the Federal Tort Claims Act, you must submit a written administrative claim to the responsible federal agency within two years of accrual. You cannot skip this step and go straight to court. If the agency denies the claim, you then have six months from the denial letter to file suit.7Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 28 USC 2401 – Time for Commencing Action Against United States
State and Local Claims
State and local government tort claims often carry even tighter notice deadlines, commonly 90 to 180 days from the incident. That is far shorter than the limitations period for the same claim against a private party. Miss the notice deadline and the claim is typically barred outright, regardless of how serious the injury. If any part of your claim involves a government entity, checking the applicable notice requirement should be the first thing you do.
Why the Accrual Date Decides Everything
The accrual date is the hinge the entire limitations analysis swings on. Personal injury claims commonly allow two to three years. Written contract disputes typically provide four to six. Some fraud claims get longer. But every one of those periods measures from accrual, so the real question is never just “how long do I have” but “how long do I have, starting when.”
The rules also layer. A discovery rule might delay accrual, but a statute of repose can override that delay with a hard cutoff. A tolling doctrine might pause the clock, but only for a statute of limitations, not for a repose period. A government claim might accrue the same day as a private claim arising from the same incident, yet the government notice deadline could expire months before the private limitations period becomes a concern.
Courts enforce these deadlines strictly, and defendants raise them at the first opportunity. If you are unsure when your claim accrued or how much time remains, that uncertainty is itself a reason to consult an attorney before the question becomes academic.