A judge can change a ruling, but when it’s possible depends almost entirely on whether the case has reached final judgment. Before final judgment, the judge who issued an order has broad authority to revisit it. After final judgment, the question of when a judge can change their ruling is governed by a short list of specific grounds and some of the strictest deadlines in civil procedure.
Before the Case Ends, the Judge Has Wide Latitude
While a case is still active, almost any ruling is open to revision. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 54(b), an order that doesn’t resolve every claim against every party can be revised at any time before the court enters a final judgment closing out the whole case.1Cornell Law School. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 54 – Judgment; Costs A discovery order, a denied motion to dismiss, a mid-trial evidentiary ruling — all of these remain changeable until the case ends.
That said, judges don’t flip positions casually. Most follow a self-imposed restraint called the “law of the case” doctrine, which discourages relitigating issues already decided within the same proceeding. To persuade a judge to reconsider a non-final ruling, you generally need to show one of three things: a change in the controlling law since the original ruling, new evidence that wasn’t available before, or a clear error of law or fact serious enough to cause injustice if left in place. Courts describe clear error as a plain, indisputable mistake that disregards controlling law or credible evidence. The burden is heavy.
What won’t work: rehashing arguments you already lost on, or raising new arguments you simply forgot to make. Judges spot that quickly, and the motion will be denied.
Clerical Errors Can Be Fixed Anytime
Some corrections aren’t bound by any deadline at all. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(a) lets a court fix clerical errors in a judgment whenever they’re noticed — a misspelled party name, a wrong date, a math mistake in a damages calculation.2Cornell Law School. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 60 – Relief from a Judgment or Order The judge can do this on their own initiative or in response to a request, and formal notice isn’t always required.
The limit is that 60(a) covers transcription errors only, not errors in judgment. If the written order doesn’t match what the judge actually decided, that’s clerical and fixable. If the judge simply made the wrong call, that’s substantive and requires a different route. Once an appeal is filed, even clerical fixes need the appellate court’s permission.
After Final Judgment: Six Grounds Under Rule 60(b)
Once a judgment is final, changing it is genuinely difficult. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b) lists six specific grounds, and courts read them narrowly so that losing parties can’t relitigate indefinitely:
- Mistake, inadvertence, surprise, or excusable neglect — for situations where a party couldn’t properly participate through no real fault of their own.
- Newly discovered evidence that couldn’t have been found earlier through reasonable effort, and that’s significant enough it would likely change the outcome.
- Fraud or misconduct by the opposing party, such as hiding evidence or presenting false testimony.
- A void judgment, meaning the court lacked jurisdiction or a party never received proper notice.
- A judgment that has been satisfied, or whose basis has been reversed, or whose forward-looking enforcement would no longer be fair.
- Any other reason justifying relief — a catch-all courts treat as a last resort, not a loophole.
All six grounds come from Rule 60(b).2Cornell Law School. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 60 – Relief from a Judgment or Order
What “Excusable Neglect” Actually Means
This one trips people up because “excusable” is doing more work than it looks. In Pioneer Investment Services v. Brunswick Associates, the Supreme Court identified several factors courts weigh: whether the other side would be harmed by granting relief, how long the delay lasted and its impact on the court’s schedule, whether the delay was within the party’s reasonable control, and whether the party acted in good faith.3Cornell Law School. Pioneer Investment Services v. Brunswick Associates Courts also consider whether clients should bear the consequences of their attorney’s mistakes. Plain carelessness or indifference to a deadline almost never qualifies, even when the underlying case had merit.
The Deadlines That Will Not Bend
Deadlines in this area are unusually rigid. Courts generally cannot extend them even with a good excuse.
- Motion to alter or amend a judgment under Rule 59: 28 days from the judgment. Courts are explicitly prohibited from extending this period.4Cornell Law School. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 59 – New Trial; Altering or Amending a Judgment
- Relief for mistake, newly discovered evidence, or fraud under Rule 60(b)(1)–(3): within one year of the judgment, and within a “reasonable time,” whichever is shorter.
- Void judgment, satisfaction, or the catch-all under Rule 60(b)(4)–(6): no fixed outer deadline, but still must be filed within a “reasonable time.” Courts decide that case by case, and waiting years without a strong reason will usually sink the motion.2Cornell Law School. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 60 – Relief from a Judgment or Order
Miss these windows and the option is gone. That’s where most people get caught — by the time they realize something went wrong, the clock has already run out.
Criminal Cases Follow Different Rules
If your matter is criminal, the civil procedures above don’t apply. Under Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 33, a court can grant a new trial if “the interests of justice so require.” A motion based on newly discovered evidence can be filed up to three years after the guilty verdict; for any other ground, the deadline is 14 days after the verdict.5Office of the Law Revision Counsel. Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 33 – New Trial
Sentences are tighter still. Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 35 gives a judge just 14 days after sentencing to correct a sentence that resulted from clear error, such as an arithmetic mistake or a misapplied guideline. After that window closes, the only route to a reduction is a government motion based on the defendant’s substantial assistance in investigating or prosecuting someone else. The government generally must file that motion within one year of sentencing, with narrow exceptions when the useful information surfaces later.6Cornell Law School. Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 35 – Correcting or Reducing a Sentence
The practical reality for a criminal defendant: a judge cannot simply decide months later that a sentence was too harsh and reduce it. Once 14 days pass, the initiative shifts to the prosecution.
Reconsideration Is Not an Appeal
A motion for reconsideration and an appeal are separate processes aimed at different audiences. A reconsideration motion goes back to the same judge who made the ruling, asking that judge to recognize an error or weigh something new. An appeal asks a higher court to review the decision, and the appellate court works only from the existing record — no new evidence, no new testimony.
The two processes do interact in one important way. Filing certain post-judgment motions, including those under Rules 59 and 60 (if filed within 28 days), resets the clock for filing an appeal.7Cornell Law School. Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure Rule 4 – Appeal as of Right; When Taken The appeal deadline doesn’t start running until the court rules on the motion. The tolling is automatic, but it only applies to timely motions. Miss the post-judgment deadline and the appeal clock keeps ticking.
The Risk of Filing a Weak Motion
Asking a judge to change a ruling carries real downside if the motion isn’t well-founded. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 11, attorneys and unrepresented parties certify that every motion has a legitimate legal and factual basis. A court that finds a motion was filed to harass, delay, or relitigate failed arguments can impose sanctions, including paying the other side’s attorney fees for responding to it, or a penalty paid directly to the court.8Cornell Law School. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 11 – Signing Pleadings, Motions, and Other Papers; Representations to the Court; Sanctions Sanctions must be proportional to the conduct, but the prospect of paying your opponent’s legal bills tends to focus the mind.
One more thing worth knowing: filing a motion to change a ruling does not freeze the judgment. Rule 60(c) states that the motion “does not affect the judgment’s finality or suspend its operation.”2Cornell Law School. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Rule 60 – Relief from a Judgment or Order The winning party can start collecting or enforcing while your motion sits with the court, unless you obtain a separate stay.