When Do Witnesses Take the Stand in a Criminal Trial?

In a criminal trial, witnesses testify after the jury has been selected and both sides have delivered opening statements. The prosecution calls its witnesses first because it carries the burden of proof, and the defense gets its turn only after the prosecution formally rests. A limited rebuttal round can follow. That is the short answer to when witnesses testify in a criminal trial; the longer answer, including who questions them and in what order, is below.

What Has to Happen First

No one takes the stand until two preliminary steps are done. Jury selection, called voir dire, comes first. The judge and attorneys question potential jurors to find people who can weigh the evidence fairly. Either side can ask the judge to remove a juror “for cause” if questioning reveals possible bias, and each side also has a limited number of peremptory challenges that remove jurors without a stated reason.1U.S. District Court. The Voir Dire Examination

Once the jury is seated, both sides deliver opening statements. The prosecution goes first and lays out what it believes the evidence will show. The defense follows with its own preview. Opening statements are not evidence. Nothing is formally introduced into the record, and no witnesses are called. They are each side’s roadmap for what the jury should watch for during the testimony to come.

The Prosecution Calls Its Witnesses First

Because the prosecution has to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, it presents evidence first. The first witness walks to the stand, takes an oath, and begins answering questions. The prosecution keeps calling witnesses until it believes it has presented enough evidence to prove every element of the charged offense. Then it formally “rests.”

How Each Witness Is Questioned

Every witness, no matter which side called them, goes through the same structured questioning. The side that called the witness conducts direct examination first. The purpose is to draw out what the witness saw, heard, knows, or has expertise in, through open-ended questions. Leading questions, the kind that suggest the answer, are generally not allowed on direct.2Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Evidence Rule 611 – Mode and Order of Examining Witnesses and Presenting Evidence

Cross-examination follows. The opposing attorney can use leading questions designed to pin the witness down to short answers, and the goal is usually to expose inconsistencies, show bias, or chip away at the witness’s credibility. Cross is limited to topics covered during direct examination and matters affecting credibility.2Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Evidence Rule 611 – Mode and Order of Examining Witnesses and Presenting Evidence

Questioning does not always end there. The side that called the witness can conduct a redirect examination to clean up anything cross muddied. The other side may then get recross. The back-and-forth continues until the judge is satisfied, the witness steps down, and the next one is called. This same sequence runs every time either party puts a witness on the stand.

The Sixth Amendment specifically protects a defendant’s right to cross-examine prosecution witnesses, and courts take any restriction on that right seriously.3Library of Congress. Right to Confront Witnesses Face-to-Face

Lay and Expert Witnesses

Most witnesses are lay witnesses, ordinary people testifying about what they personally saw, heard, or experienced. A lay witness can offer opinions only if those opinions are based on their own perception and are helpful to understanding the facts.4Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Evidence Rule 701 – Opinion Testimony by Lay Witnesses Expert witnesses, like a forensic scientist explaining DNA results or a medical examiner describing a cause of death, are allowed to give specialized analysis after the court finds them qualified through knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education, and finds their testimony based on reliable methods.5Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Evidence Rule 702 – Testimony by Expert Witnesses Either type can be called by either side.

The Pause Between the Two Sides

After the prosecution rests, there is a step many people do not realize exists. The defense can ask the judge to end the case right there by filing a motion for judgment of acquittal. The argument is that even viewing the prosecution’s evidence in the light most favorable to the government, no reasonable jury could convict. If the judge agrees, the case is over and the defense never calls a witness.6Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 29 – Motion for a Judgment of Acquittal

Judges grant these motions rarely. If the motion is denied, the defense proceeds normally without having waived anything, and the motion can be renewed after all evidence is in or within 14 days of a guilty verdict.6Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 29 – Motion for a Judgment of Acquittal

Defense Witnesses

If the case continues, the defense calls its witnesses. These might include alibi witnesses, character witnesses, or experts who challenge the prosecution’s scientific evidence. The examination mechanics are identical: defense counsel conducts direct examination, the prosecutor cross-examines, and redirect and recross may follow.

The defense is not obligated to call anyone. Because the prosecution carries the entire burden of proof, the defense can rest without presenting a single witness if it believes the prosecution has not met that burden. It happens more often than people assume, and it is a legitimate strategic choice.

The Defendant’s Decision Whether to Testify

The defendant can testify but is never required to. Federal law has protected this since 1878: a person charged with a crime is a competent witness only “at his own request,” and refusing to testify “shall not create any presumption against him.”7Office of the Law Revision Counsel. U.S. Code Title 18 Section 3481 The prosecutor cannot comment on the choice to stay silent, and the judge cannot tell the jury to treat silence as evidence of guilt. The Supreme Court established that rule in 1965 under the Fifth Amendment.8Justia. Griffin v. California, 380 U.S. 609 On request, the judge will instruct the jury not to hold the defendant’s silence against them in any way.9United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit. Pattern Criminal Jury Instructions – Special Evidentiary Matters

A defendant who does take the stand gives up some of that protection. Testifying waives Fifth Amendment protections on the topics covered during direct examination and opens the door to prosecution cross-examination on those subjects. That tradeoff makes the decision to testify one of the most consequential strategic calls in the whole trial.

Rebuttal and Surrebuttal

After the defense rests, the prosecution may call rebuttal witnesses. The purpose is narrow: responding to specific evidence or testimony the defense introduced. Rebuttal is not a second chance to present the main case or to introduce evidence that should have come in earlier. If the defense put on an alibi witness, for example, the prosecution might call a rebuttal witness to contradict that alibi.

If the rebuttal raises new points, the defense may be allowed to call surrebuttal witnesses. This phase is uncommon and equally limited. The judge controls how far these additional rounds go, and testimony has to stay tightly connected to whatever it is rebutting. Once rebuttal rounds end, no more witnesses can be called.

When Witnesses Must Appear, and When They Can Watch

Witnesses do not always come willingly. Either side can have a subpoena issued, which in federal criminal cases must identify the court, name the proceeding, and order the witness to appear at a specific time and place. It can be served anywhere in the United States.10Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure Rule 17 – Subpoena A witness who ignores a subpoena without a valid excuse can be held in contempt of court.

A witness waiting to testify generally cannot sit in the gallery and watch the trial first. Either party can ask the judge to exclude witnesses from the courtroom so they cannot hear other witnesses’ testimony, and judges routinely grant these requests; the court can also order exclusion on its own.11Legal Information Institute. Federal Rules of Evidence Rule 615 – Excluding Witnesses The point is to keep one witness from shaping testimony around what another already said. The defendant can always remain in the courtroom, and crime victims have their own federal protections against being excluded from public proceedings unless the court finds clear and convincing evidence that hearing other testimony would materially alter their own.12U.S. Department of Justice. Crime Victims’ Rights Act