When you sue someone and win, the money usually comes from the defendant’s liability insurance. If insurance doesn’t apply or doesn’t cover the full amount, it comes from the defendant’s own bank accounts, wages, and property that isn’t legally protected from creditors. Roughly 95 percent of civil cases settle before trial, and those settlements are overwhelmingly paid by insurers. What you actually walk away with has less to do with the size of your judgment than with what the defendant has and whether anyone is insuring them.
Insurance Pays Most Lawsuit Recoveries
Car accidents, slip-and-falls, professional malpractice, dog bites, business injuries — in almost all of these, a liability insurance policy stands behind the defendant. The policy pays for the defense lawyer, negotiates with you or your attorney, and funds the settlement or judgment up to its limits. The defendant personally is often barely involved in the money side at all.
Different policies cover different events. Auto liability covers crashes. Homeowners covers accidents on the property and some off-property claims. Professional liability (also called errors and omissions or malpractice coverage) covers claims against doctors, lawyers, accountants, and other professionals. Businesses typically carry commercial general liability. Each policy spells out what’s covered, what’s excluded, and the ceiling on what the insurer will pay.
That ceiling matters. If the at-fault driver carries $100,000 in bodily injury coverage and your damages come to $250,000, the insurer owes $100,000 and no more. The remaining $150,000 is a claim against the driver personally, and collecting that is a different kind of fight.
Insurers aren’t always cooperative. They have a duty to defend any lawsuit that could potentially fall within coverage and a duty to investigate and attempt to settle claims in good faith. When an insurer wrongly refuses to defend or settle, the policyholder may have a “bad faith” claim against the insurer, which can sometimes open up money beyond the stated policy limit.
The Defendant’s Personal Money and Property
When there’s no insurance, or when the judgment exceeds the policy limit, you’re collecting from the defendant personally. That means bank accounts, real estate, vehicles, investment accounts, and other valuable property. You cannot just take any of it. You need a court judgment stating the exact amount owed, and then you have to use enforcement tools to reach specific assets.
Every state shields some property from creditors through exemption laws. These typically protect a portion of home equity (the homestead exemption), a basic vehicle, essential household goods, retirement accounts, and tools of the trade. Homestead exemptions range from roughly $50,000 to several hundred thousand dollars depending on the state, and a few states offer unlimited homestead protection. Vehicle exemptions usually protect a few thousand dollars in equity. Anything over the exempt amount can be reached.
Jointly held property complicates things. In about half the states, married couples can hold property as “tenancy by the entirety,” which generally keeps a creditor of one spouse from seizing it. That protection falls away if both spouses are on the judgment, or if the couple divorces, or if one spouse dies.
Defendants sometimes try to move assets to relatives, friends, or shell entities once a lawsuit is on the horizon. Nearly every state has adopted a version of the Uniform Voidable Transactions Act, which lets creditors challenge transfers made to hinder collection or made for less than fair value when the defendant was already insolvent. A court can reverse the transfer and make the property available to pay your judgment.
How You Actually Collect a Judgment
The court does not send you a check. Winning gives you the legal right to collect; the collecting is your job. Which tool you reach for depends on what the defendant has.
Finding Out What the Defendant Owns
You can’t go after assets you don’t know about. Courts allow post-judgment discovery, including a debtor’s examination: you file a motion, the court orders the defendant to appear and answer questions under oath, and the defendant can be required to bring bank statements, tax returns, and pay stubs. Skipping the exam can result in contempt, and in some places a bench warrant.
Wage Garnishment
Garnishment redirects part of the defendant’s paycheck to you. Once you have a garnishment order, the employer withholds a portion of each paycheck and sends it to you until the judgment is paid. Federal law limits garnishment for ordinary debts to the lesser of 25 percent of disposable earnings or the amount by which weekly disposable earnings exceed 30 times the federal minimum wage, which puts the protected floor at $217.50 per week at the $7.25 federal minimum.1Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 15 USC 1673 – Restriction on Garnishment Some states cap garnishment more tightly. Employers must comply.
Judgment Liens on Real Estate
Recording your judgment with the county attaches a lien to any real estate the defendant owns there. The defendant then can’t sell or refinance the property without clearing the lien, which means paying you. It’s effective because most people eventually need to sell or refinance. It also takes patience, because that moment may be years away.
Installment Payments
When the defendant has steady income but no lump sum, courts can approve a payment plan. The defendant lays out their finances and proposes a schedule; if approved, you get regular payments over time. Missed payments can trigger further enforcement. It’s often the realistic outcome when the defendant works but has little in the bank.
When the Defendant Has Nothing to Take
A defendant with no meaningful income, no real estate, and no non-exempt assets is “judgment proof.” Your judgment is still valid, and the defendant still owes you, but there is nothing to collect right now.
That can change. If the defendant later gets a well-paying job, inherits money, or buys property, your judgment becomes collectible again. A recorded lien attaches to real estate they acquire later. Garnishment opens up once they’re employed. The judgment doesn’t disappear just because the defendant is broke today.
Some income is permanently off-limits regardless of how much the defendant has in total. Federal law protects Social Security benefits, Supplemental Security Income, unemployment benefits, veterans’ benefits, and federal retirement benefits from garnishment for most civil judgments. Those funds can’t be reached even when the defendant has nothing else.
This is why experienced attorneys evaluate the defendant’s ability to pay before taking a case. A strong case against someone with no insurance and no assets can produce a judgment worth nothing.
Interest and How Long the Judgment Lasts
An unpaid judgment grows. In federal court, interest runs from the date judgment is entered at a rate tied to the weekly average one-year Treasury yield, compounded annually.2Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 28 USC 1961 – Interest State post-judgment interest rates vary, typically between 4 and 12 percent. On a $200,000 judgment at 8 percent, that’s $16,000 a year added on.
Judgments do have shelf lives. Depending on the state, a civil judgment stays enforceable anywhere from 5 to 20 years, with 10 years the most common. Most states let you renew the judgment before it expires and restart the clock. Miss the renewal window and the judgment expires with it. That matters most when you’re waiting out a judgment-proof defendant for their finances to turn around.
When the Defendant Is a Business
If the defendant is a corporation or LLC, you collect from the company’s own assets first: its bank accounts, equipment, inventory, accounts receivable, and real property. Owners generally are not personally liable for company debts. That’s the point of the entity.
Courts will “pierce the corporate veil” and reach the owner’s personal assets in limited circumstances, usually where the business was a shell with no real separation from the owner’s personal finances. Judges look at whether the owner mixed personal and business funds, ignored corporate formalities, left the business drastically undercapitalized, or used the entity specifically to dodge personal liability. No single factor decides it, but the more the entity looks like an alter ego, the better your chance.
Piercing is hard to win. Courts start from a strong presumption that the corporate form stands. If the business operated as a genuine separate entity, you’re stuck with whatever the business itself owns, and if the business has folded, that may be nothing.
When You’re Suing the Government
Suing a government entity runs on different rules. Sovereign immunity means the federal and state governments can’t be sued unless they’ve agreed to it, and both have agreed only partially and with conditions.
The Federal Tort Claims Act allows lawsuits against the federal government for injuries caused by the negligence of federal employees acting within the scope of their jobs. You cannot go straight to court. You must first submit a written administrative claim to the agency responsible, within two years of the injury, describing what happened and stating the exact dollar amount you want.3Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 28 USC 2675 – Disposition by Federal Agency as Prerequisite; Evidence You cannot later sue for more than the amount in that claim. The agency has six months to accept or deny; if denied, you have six months to file suit, and if the agency doesn’t respond within six months you can treat the silence as a denial. The federal government cannot be made to pay punitive damages, only compensatory damages.4Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 28 USC 2674 – Liability of United States
State and local governments each have their own tort claims act. These usually require a notice of claim within a short window, sometimes as little as 60 to 180 days after the incident, far shorter than the normal statute of limitations. Miss that notice deadline and the claim is dead no matter how strong it was. Many states also cap damages against government entities well below what a private defendant could be forced to pay. Checking your state’s rules early is critical because the deadlines are short and the procedures vary heavily.
If the Defendant Files for Bankruptcy
Bankruptcy is the worst development for a judgment creditor. The moment the defendant files, an automatic stay halts virtually all collection: garnishments stop, lien enforcement freezes, and you cannot take any further step to collect until the bankruptcy court lifts the stay or the case ends.5Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 11 USC 362 – Automatic Stay
In Chapter 7, a trustee sells the debtor’s non-exempt assets and distributes the proceeds to creditors, including you.6United States Courts. Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Basics When it ends, most remaining debts are discharged — wiped out. If your judgment is discharged, the defendant owes you nothing. Many judgment creditors receive pennies on the dollar, or nothing.
In Chapter 13, the defendant keeps their property and makes payments under a court-approved plan lasting three to five years. Creditors receive payments based on the debtor’s disposable income and the priority of their claim.7United States Courts. Chapter 13 – Bankruptcy Basics You’ll likely get a fraction of what you’re owed, but it comes in on a schedule.
Some judgments survive bankruptcy. The Bankruptcy Code lists exceptions to discharge for debts arising from fraud, willful and malicious injury, and death or personal injury caused by drunk driving.8Office of the Law Revision Counsel. 11 USC 523 – Exceptions to Discharge If your judgment fits one of these, it survives and remains fully enforceable after the case closes, though you may need to file an adversary proceeding inside the bankruptcy to establish that it qualifies.
If you hold a judgment and the defendant files for bankruptcy, file a proof of claim before the deadline. Missing it can mean receiving nothing from any distribution the case produces, even when the debtor has assets to distribute.