In England and Wales, the people who can contest a will fall into two groups: those who would inherit more if the will were set aside (usually beneficiaries of an earlier will or relatives who would take under the intestacy rules), and a defined list of family members and dependants who can ask the court for reasonable financial provision under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975. Who can contest a will in the UK depends partly on which route you take and partly on where the deceased was domiciled, because Scotland and Northern Ireland have their own succession rules.
Disliking the terms of a will is not enough. You need a direct legal interest in the outcome, and the nature of that interest shapes everything that follows.
Who Has Standing to Challenge Validity
If you want the will declared invalid, you generally need to show you would gain something if it fell away. In practice that means one of two things. Either you were named in a previous valid will that gave you more, or you would inherit under the intestacy rules that apply when there is no valid will.
Under intestacy in England and Wales, the surviving spouse or civil partner takes the first £322,000 of the estate plus half of what remains, and children split the other half. If there is no spouse or civil partner, children inherit equally. Unmarried partners, stepchildren who were never formally adopted, and friends receive nothing on intestacy. That matters for standing: if you fall into one of those categories and were not named in an earlier will, you usually cannot challenge validity, because overturning the will would not benefit you. Your route, if you have one, is the Inheritance Act.
Who Can Claim Under the Inheritance Act 1975
The Inheritance Act 1975 is a different kind of challenge. You accept that the will is genuine and valid; you argue it fails to provide reasonably for you, and ask the court to adjust what you receive. The Act lists who can bring a claim:1Legislation.gov.uk. Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975
- A spouse or civil partner of the deceased.
- A former spouse or civil partner who has not remarried or entered a new civil partnership.
- A cohabitant who lived with the deceased as a couple for at least two years immediately before the death.
- A child of the deceased, including an adopted child.
- A child of the family, meaning someone who was not biologically the deceased’s child but was treated as a child of the family within a marriage or civil partnership the deceased was part of.
- Any person who was being financially maintained by the deceased, wholly or partly, immediately before the death.
The cohabitant threshold catches people out. Eighteen months of living together is not enough, however serious the relationship. If you miss the two-year mark, your only route under the Act is to show you were financially maintained by the deceased.
The standard the court applies also depends on which category you fall into. For a surviving spouse or civil partner, the court looks at what would be reasonable in all the circumstances, with no limit tied to maintenance. For everyone else, the question is narrower: did the will provide enough for your maintenance? That distinction matters most for adult children. English law does not guarantee an adult child a share of a parent’s estate, and an adult child in good health with a stable income faces a difficult claim, because the court will ask whether they genuinely need maintenance from the estate at all. The strongest Inheritance Act claims typically come from minor children, disabled dependants, and spouses who were left little or nothing.
Grounds for Challenging a Will’s Validity
If you have standing to attack validity, several grounds are recognised. More than one can apply to the same will.
Lack of Testamentary Capacity
The testator must have had the mental ability to make a will when they signed it. The test from Banks v Goodfellow (1870) requires the person to have understood what making a will means, to have known roughly what they owned, and to have been able to weigh who might reasonably expect to benefit. A mental disorder that distorted their judgment or affections can also defeat capacity.2The Gazette. What Are the Grounds for Contesting a Will – Section: The Deceased Did Not Have the Required Testamentary Capacity
Medical records usually drive these cases. A dementia diagnosis does not automatically invalidate a will, because capacity can fluctuate, but it does shift the burden onto those defending the will to show the testator was lucid at the moment of signing.
Undue Influence
This applies when someone coerced or pressured the testator into terms they would not otherwise have chosen. The bar is deliberately high. You must show that the testator’s free will was overridden, not merely that someone made suggestions or expressed preferences. Courts look at the relationship between the testator and the alleged influencer, whether the testator was physically or emotionally vulnerable, and whether the will’s provisions depart sharply from what the testator previously said or did.3The Gazette. What Are the Grounds for Contesting a Will – Section: Undue Influence
Improper Execution
A will in England and Wales must be in writing, signed by the testator (or by someone else at the testator’s direction and in their presence), and witnessed by two people who were both present when the testator signed or acknowledged the signature. Each witness must then sign in the testator’s presence.4Legislation.gov.uk. Wills Act 1837 – Section 9
Skip a step and the will fails. Common problems include a witness who was not actually in the room at the moment of signing, a witness who is also a beneficiary (which does not invalidate the will but voids that witness’s gift), or an ambiguous mark that was never properly acknowledged.
Fraud, Forgery, and Lack of Knowledge and Approval
A forged signature or fabricated document voids the will. Fraud can also mean the testator was deliberately misled about the will’s contents or about a beneficiary’s character. Separately, a will can fail for lack of knowledge and approval if the testator did not truly understand what the document said, even though they signed it. This often arises when someone else prepared the will and the testator signed without reading carefully, particularly if they were elderly, visually impaired, or heavily medicated.5The Gazette. What Are the Grounds for Contesting a Will – Section: Fraud or Forgery
Rectification
Rectification is narrower than a full validity challenge. The will is genuine, but a clerical error or a mistake by the drafter means the document does not reflect what the testator actually instructed. The court can order the wording corrected rather than striking the will down. Applications must be made within six months of the grant of probate, though the court has limited power to extend.6Legislation.gov.uk. Administration of Justice Act 1982 – Section 20
Time Limits
Standing is worth nothing if you miss the deadline, and the deadlines vary by claim type.
- Inheritance Act claims must be issued within six months of the grant of probate. The court can extend this, but only with permission, and only where there is a compelling reason for the delay.1Legislation.gov.uk. Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975
- Rectification claims carry the same six-month deadline from the grant of probate, with limited discretion to extend.6Legislation.gov.uk. Administration of Justice Act 1982 – Section 20
- Validity challenges based on lack of capacity, undue influence, or fraud have no fixed statutory deadline. But delay hurts. Once the estate has been distributed, recovering assets from beneficiaries who have already spent them becomes very difficult. Executors who distribute after the six-month post-probate period are generally protected from personal liability for claims that surface later.
If you suspect a problem, you can lodge a caveat with the Probate Registry. A caveat stops anyone from obtaining a grant of probate, which freezes the estate while you investigate. Anyone can lodge one, it lasts six months, and it can be extended for another six.7GOV.UK. Stopping a Probate Application Only lodge a caveat if you genuinely intend to pursue a claim; using one purely to delay the executors can lead to costs consequences.
What About a No-Contest Clause
Some wills include a no-contest clause (also called a forfeiture clause) saying that any beneficiary who challenges the will forfeits their inheritance. These clauses are generally enforceable in England and Wales when clearly drafted, but they are not absolute. A court will not let a no-contest clause automatically defeat an Inheritance Act claim by someone who was financially dependent on the deceased. And a beneficiary who challenges on grounds like undue influence or lack of capacity may be allowed to proceed where the court finds the concerns were reasonably raised. A no-contest clause raises the stakes of a failed challenge, but it does not strip you of the legal right to bring one.
What It Costs
Legal aid has not been available for probate disputes in England and Wales since 2013, so you fund the claim yourself or find another arrangement. Reaching a negotiated settlement typically costs tens of thousands of pounds. Taking a case all the way through trial can run into six figures on each side in complex estates. The general civil litigation rule applies: the loser usually pays the winner’s costs. Losing a will challenge can mean more than missing out on the estate; you may owe the other side’s legal bills.
Some solicitors offer “no win, no fee” arrangements for strong Inheritance Act claims, especially where the estate is large enough to absorb the risk. After-the-event insurance can cover the other side’s costs if you lose, with the premium deferred until the outcome. Not every case qualifies, and solicitors assess the merits before agreeing.
Scotland and Northern Ireland
Everything above applies to England and Wales. If the deceased was domiciled elsewhere in the UK, different rules govern.
In Scotland, a will needs only one witness rather than two, and the system of “legal rights” automatically entitles a surviving spouse and children to a fixed share of the moveable estate regardless of what the will says. There is no direct equivalent of the Inheritance Act 1975 in Scotland, because legal rights provide baseline protection without a court application. Challenges to validity are raised in the Court of Session or sheriff court under separate procedural rules.
Northern Ireland has its own version of the Inheritance Act (the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) (Northern Ireland) Order 1979) and the Wills and Administration Proceedings (Northern Ireland) Order 1994 governs execution. The principles track England and Wales closely, but the specific rules and procedures differ. If the deceased lived in Scotland or Northern Ireland, speak to a solicitor qualified in that jurisdiction rather than relying on guidance written for England and Wales.