Who Was the First Black Judge in America?

The first Black judge in America was Macon Bolling Allen, appointed Justice of the Peace for Middlesex County, Massachusetts, in 1847 by Governor George N. Briggs.1Massachusetts Historical Society. Passing the Bar: America’s First African-American Attorney Allen was already the first African American admitted to the bar in any state, and the 1847 commission made him the first African American to exercise official judicial authority anywhere in the United States.

Who Macon Bolling Allen Was

Allen was born in Indiana in 1816 under the name A. Macon Bolling. He later took the surname Allen, though the reason is not well documented. He worked as a schoolteacher before turning to law.

He trained the way almost every lawyer did in that era: by apprenticing with practicing attorneys. His mentors were two white abolitionist lawyers in New England, Samuel Fessenden and Samuel E. Sewall.1Massachusetts Historical Society. Passing the Bar: America’s First African-American Attorney There were no law schools or formal bar associations in the modern sense. A would-be lawyer paid an established attorney for instruction and courtroom experience, then sat for an oral examination given by a judge or senior lawyer in the jurisdiction where he wanted to practice.2Library of Congress. The History of the U.S. Bar Exam, Part I – The Law’s Gatekeeper

Allen cleared that bar on July 3, 1844, in Maine, becoming the first African American licensed to practice law in the United States.3National Underground Railroad Freedom Center. Freedom Center Tells Story of Nation’s First African American Lawyer Portland had few clients for a Black attorney, so he moved to Boston and was admitted to the Massachusetts bar on May 7, 1845 after passing an examination.1Massachusetts Historical Society. Passing the Bar: America’s First African-American Attorney William Lloyd Garrison’s abolitionist newspaper The Liberator covered his arrival. Two years later, the judicial appointment followed.

What the 1847 Appointment Involved

A Justice of the Peace in antebellum Massachusetts sat on the lowest rung of the judiciary. The role was not symbolic, though. Justices of the Peace heard small civil disputes, administered oaths, and performed marriages. They had to know local ordinances and resolve conflicts quickly.

The scope was modest. The significance was not. For the first time in American history, a Black man held a commission from a state to interpret and apply the law from a seat of authority rather than stand before it as a subject or a petitioner. Governor Briggs, a Whig and former U.S. representative, signed the commission.

Allen’s Later Judicial Offices in South Carolina

Allen’s judicial career did not end in Middlesex County. After the Civil War he moved south, was admitted to the South Carolina bar in November 1869, and joined William Whipper and Robert Brown Elliott to form what was likely the first African American law firm in the country.4University of South Carolina School of Law. All for Civil Rights: Macon Bolling Allen (1816-1894) The firm was based in Charleston.

In 1873 the South Carolina legislature elected him Judge of the Charleston County Criminal Court. In 1876 he was elected Probate Judge for Charleston County, defeating the white incumbent.3National Underground Railroad Freedom Center. Freedom Center Tells Story of Nation’s First African American Lawyer These were real judicial posts with jurisdiction over criminal prosecutions and estates, well beyond anything a Justice of the Peace handled.

Allen served as probate judge until around 1878, when the collapse of Reconstruction ended most Black officeholding in the South. He moved to Washington, D.C., worked as an attorney for the Land and Improvement Association, and died on October 15, 1894, at age 78.4University of South Carolina School of Law. All for Civil Rights: Macon Bolling Allen (1816-1894) His legal career ran roughly fifty years across four jurisdictions.

Other Early African American Judicial Firsts

Several other names come up alongside Allen’s, and it helps to keep them straight.

Robert Morris

Robert Morris became the second African American to practice law in Massachusetts, starting in 1847, and by the early 1850s he had been appointed a justice of the peace and occasionally sat as a magistrate in courts in Boston and Chelsea.5National Park Service. Robert Morris He came after Allen on the bench, but he was among the very earliest Black Americans to exercise judicial power in any form.

Jonathan Jasper Wright

On February 1, 1870, the South Carolina General Assembly elected Jonathan Jasper Wright as an associate justice of the state Supreme Court. He was the first African American to serve on any state supreme court in the country.6South Carolina Historical Society. February 1870: First African American Elected to the South Carolina Supreme Court Wright, from Pennsylvania, had worked for the Freedmen’s Bureau providing legal assistance to newly freed Black South Carolinians. He served nearly seven years before a resolution calling for an investigation forced him off the bench in 1877. No African American sat on a state supreme court again for close to a century.

William Henry Hastie

The federal judiciary took much longer. In 1937, President Franklin D. Roosevelt appointed William Henry Hastie to the Federal District Court of the Virgin Islands, making Hastie the first African American federal judge in United States history. In 1949 Hastie became the first Black federal appellate judge when he was appointed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit.

Thurgood Marshall

In 1967, President Lyndon B. Johnson appointed Thurgood Marshall as an Associate Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court, making him the first African American on the nation’s highest court.7Oyez. Thurgood Marshall Marshall had argued and won Brown v. Board of Education before the Court in 1954 as lead counsel for the NAACP Legal Defense Fund.

Jane Bolin and Constance Baker Motley

All the firsts above were men. In 1939, Mayor Fiorello La Guardia appointed Jane Bolin, a Yale Law School graduate, to the New York City Domestic Relations Court, making her the first African American woman judge in the United States. She served nearly forty years, until 1978.8Yale Law School. Historical Profile: Jane Matilda Bolin ’31 In 1966, President Johnson appointed Constance Baker Motley to the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, making her the first African American woman on the federal bench. Like Marshall, Motley had litigated civil rights cases for the NAACP Legal Defense Fund before taking the bench.

Why Allen’s Appointment Still Matters

Allen’s 1847 commission carried a small jurisdiction and a modest salary. What it carried permanently was precedent. A Black man had been seated under state authority to apply the law, and that fact could not be reversed. Every later milestone, from Wright on the South Carolina Supreme Court to Marshall on the U.S. Supreme Court, built on the ground Allen reached first. He died in 1894, more than fifty years before the federal bench would see its first Black judge.