Why the Death Penalty Should Be Abolished: Cost, Bias, and Error

There are strong reasons why the death penalty should be abolished in the United States, and they rest on evidence rather than sentiment. At least 202 people sentenced to death since 1973 have later been exonerated. Decades of research have failed to show that executions deter murder. Capital cases cost far more than life without parole. The sentence is handed down unequally depending on the race of the victim, the wealth of the defendant, and the county where the crime occurred. And the mechanics of carrying out executions have grown more chaotic, not less. Twenty-three states and Washington, D.C. have already eliminated capital punishment, and governors in California, Oregon, Pennsylvania, and Ohio maintain moratoriums that halt executions without repealing the underlying statutes.1Death Penalty Information Center. State by State

Innocent People Are Sentenced to Death

Since 1973, at least 202 people sentenced to death have been exonerated after evidence showed they did not commit the crime.2Death Penalty Information Center. Innocence Many of those exonerations came decades after conviction. More than half of all current death row prisoners have been awaiting their fate for over eighteen years.3Death Penalty Information Center. Time on Death Row

The causes of wrongful convictions are well-documented and ordinary. False testimony and fabricated accusations account for more than half of overturned cases. Mistaken eyewitness identifications, coerced confessions, unreliable forensic techniques like bite-mark comparisons and hair microscopy, and jailhouse informants trading testimony for sentence reductions all contribute. Overworked and underfunded defense lawyers who lack the resources to challenge the prosecution’s evidence round out the list.4Equal Justice Initiative. Wrongful Convictions These are features of a system running under normal budget and caseload pressures, not exotic failures.

DNA testing has uncovered many of these errors, but biological evidence does not exist in every case. When it does, it is sometimes lost, degraded, or never tested during the original investigation. “Beyond a reasonable doubt” is a high standard, but it cannot be perfect when the inputs — witness memories, forensic analysis, investigative choices — are themselves fallible. A sentence of life without parole preserves the possibility of correction. A death sentence does not. Once an execution is carried out, no court can undo it.

It Does Not Deter Murder

The most common justification for capital punishment is that it discourages people from killing. The evidence for that claim is remarkably thin. The National Research Council examined decades of deterrence research and found that studies reached “widely varying, even contradictory, conclusions.”5National Academies Press. Deterrence and the Death Penalty – Chapter 1 As early as 1978, the NRC concluded that available studies provided no useful evidence on the death penalty’s deterrent effect, and a 2012 review found the research still could not reliably separate capital punishment’s influence from the many other factors that drive homicide rates.

The raw numbers point in the opposite direction from what deterrence advocates predict. States that carry out executions consistently report higher murder rates than states without the death penalty: 4.7 murders per 100,000 people compared to 3.8, according to a Death Penalty Information Center analysis of FBI data.6Death Penalty Information Center. FBI Crime Report Shows Murder Rates Remain Higher in Death Penalty States Many variables drive those rates, and correlation is not causation. But if executions were the powerful deterrent supporters describe, you would expect at least a visible trend in the other direction.

Part of the problem is that the death penalty, as practiced, is too rare and too delayed to function as a deterrent. The average time between sentencing and execution stretches past two decades in some states, and most death sentences are overturned or converted to other punishments long before an execution date arrives. A punishment that might arrive twenty years from now, or might never arrive at all, is a poor candidate for influencing split-second decisions driven by rage, desperation, or mental illness.

It Costs More Than Life Without Parole

Maintaining capital punishment costs far more than sentencing someone to life without parole, and the expense gap shows up at every stage. Capital trials require specialized attorneys on both sides, longer jury selection, more expert witnesses, and a separate sentencing phase after the guilt-or-innocence verdict. In Nevada, defense costs alone ran $170,000 to $212,000 more per case than a comparable non-capital murder prosecution.7Death Penalty Information Center. Costs: Death Penalty Cases in Nevada Cost $200K Extra, Just for Defense That figure covers only the defense side of one trial, excluding the prosecution’s matching expenditures, court administration, and the decades of appeals that follow.

Those appeals are not optional. Because the government is seeking to end a person’s life, the Constitution requires extensive review. Death-sentenced prisoners typically spend more than a decade in post-conviction proceedings, and in many states the average exceeds twenty years.3Death Penalty Information Center. Time on Death Row Each round of review requires court-appointed attorneys, state-funded prosecutors, judicial staff time, and written opinions at multiple levels.

Housing adds another layer. Condemned prisoners are held in single cells under heightened security with higher staff-to-inmate ratios. One state study found the annual cost of incarcerating a death row prisoner was roughly $85,000, compared with about $45,000 for a prisoner serving life without parole.8Death Penalty Information Center. Costs Add the trial premium, decades of appeals, and the housing surcharge, and the total cost of a single death penalty case can exceed the cost of imprisoning someone for life by a wide margin, all for a system that results in relatively few executions.

It Is Applied Unequally

Death sentences are not distributed based on the severity of the crime. They are distributed based on where the crime happened, who the victim was, and how much money the defendant has. That pattern has persisted for decades and sits uneasily beside the Fourteenth Amendment’s promise that no state shall deny any person the equal protection of the laws.9Congress.gov. U.S. Constitution – Fourteenth Amendment

Race of the Victim

The most thoroughly documented disparity involves the race of the victim. Professor David Baldus found that defendants charged with killing white victims were 4.3 times as likely to receive a death sentence as those charged with killing Black victims, even after accounting for thirty-nine non-racial variables.10Cornell Law Institute. McCleskey v. Kemp, 481 U.S. 279 That was not an isolated finding. A federal review of sentencing research found that 82 percent of studies identified the race of the victim as a factor correlated with receiving a death sentence.11Office of Justice Programs. Death Penalty Sentencing: Research Indicates Pattern of Racial Disparities In McCleskey v. Kemp, the Supreme Court acknowledged the Baldus study’s statistical power but ruled that system-wide statistical evidence of racial disparity was insufficient to prove discrimination in an individual case, effectively closing the courthouse door to this type of challenge.

Wealth and Representation

A defendant’s resources shape capital outcomes in ways unrelated to guilt. Someone with money hires experienced attorneys, private investigators, forensic experts, and mitigation specialists. Someone without money receives a court-appointed lawyer whose hourly rate is capped and whose caseload may already be overwhelming. The gap between those two defense efforts translates directly into who ends up sentenced to death versus who pleads to a lesser charge.

Geography

The majority of death sentences in the United States come from just 34 of the country’s more than 3,100 counties. A person could face execution for a crime that would yield a prison sentence in the next county over, depending on the local prosecutor’s preferences and budget. When prosecutors in one jurisdiction are far more likely to seek death than prosecutors handling similar cases nearby, the sentence reflects local politics rather than proportional justice.

Executions Themselves Are Increasingly Botched

Lethal injection, adopted as a supposedly humane alternative to the electric chair and gas chamber, has a documented failure rate of 7.2 percent, the highest botched-execution rate of any method used since 1890.12Death Penalty Information Center. Botched Executions A botched execution means the prisoner experienced unnecessary agony from wrong drug dosages, failed IV lines, or other procedural breakdowns.

The problem deepened after 2010, when pharmaceutical companies began refusing to supply drugs for executions. The sole domestic manufacturer of one key drug left the market, and international legislation made importing alternatives nearly impossible.13The Philosophy, Politics, and Economics Review. Pharmaceutical Firms Against Lethal Injection and the Ramifications States turned to compounding pharmacies and untested drug combinations, and prolonged, visibly painful executions have followed.

Alabama carried out the first-ever execution by nitrogen hypoxia in January 2024. State attorneys had assured courts the method would cause unconsciousness in seconds. Witnesses reported the prisoner shook and writhed for at least four minutes before breathing heavily for several more. He was pronounced dead thirty-two minutes after the execution began.14Death Penalty Information Center. “The World is Watching”: Witnesses Report Kenneth Smith Appeared Conscious, Shook and Writhed During First-Ever Nitrogen Hypoxia Execution At least four states now authorize nitrogen hypoxia, and others have revived the firing squad and electric chair as backup options. Each new method arrives with the same promise of humane efficiency.

Protections for Vulnerable Defendants Are Incomplete

The Supreme Court has carved out categorical exemptions from the death penalty for certain groups, but the protections are narrower than most people assume and inconsistently enforced.

  • Roper v. Simmons (2005) held that the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments forbid imposing the death penalty on anyone who was under eighteen at the time of the crime.15Justia. Roper v. Simmons, 543 U.S. 551
  • Atkins v. Virginia (2002) barred executing individuals with intellectual disabilities, but left each state to define who qualifies. Some states adopted rigid IQ cutoffs the Court later said were impermissible, producing years of litigation over a question that was supposedly settled.16Justia. Atkins v. Virginia, 536 U.S. 304
  • Ford v. Wainwright (1986) prohibits executing a prisoner who is “unaware of the punishment they are about to suffer and why they are to suffer it.” That protects only prisoners who have completely lost rational understanding, not those with severe mental illness who retain some awareness.17Cornell Law Institute. Ford v. Wainwright, 477 U.S. 399

Children and people with mental disabilities are especially vulnerable to wrongful convictions in the first place, partly because they are more susceptible to coercive interrogation tactics and false confessions.4Equal Justice Initiative. Wrongful Convictions A system that recognizes these vulnerabilities at sentencing but not during investigation and trial addresses the symptom rather than the cause.

It Often Harms the Victims’ Families It Claims to Serve

Capital punishment is often defended as necessary for murder victims’ families, but research on what those families actually experience tells a different story. The decades-long appeals process forces family members to relive the original trauma at every hearing, every motion, every new court date. One study found that only 2.5 percent of co-victims reported achieving true closure from an execution, and about 20 percent said the execution did not help them heal at all.18Ohioans to Stop Executions. Murder Victims and Their Family Members

A Marquette University Law School study found that when life sentences were imposed instead of death, victims’ family members reported better physical and psychological health and greater satisfaction with the justice system. Some families have become vocal advocates for abolition, arguing that another killing does not restore what was lost and that the resources consumed by the capital punishment system would be better spent on services that actually help survivors heal.19Death Penalty Information Center. Victims’ Families Family members who hold this view report feeling marginalized by prosecutors and victim advocates who assume every bereaved family wants the harshest possible punishment.

The Constitutional and International Direction Points Toward Abolition

The Eighth Amendment prohibits “cruel and unusual punishments,” and the Supreme Court has interpreted that phrase as evolving with society’s standards of decency rather than being frozen in 1791.20Congress.gov. U.S. Constitution – Eighth Amendment That framework produced the categorical exemptions for juveniles and intellectually disabled defendants, and it anchors ongoing arguments that the death penalty itself has become unconstitutional. The Court struck down existing death penalty statutes as arbitrary and racially discriminatory in Furman v. Georgia (1972), then approved rewritten statutes in Gregg v. Georgia (1976).21Justia. Gregg v. Georgia, 428 U.S. 153 The evidence accumulated since Gregg suggests those procedural safeguards have not eliminated the arbitrariness and bias that Furman identified.

More than 70 percent of the world’s countries have abolished capital punishment in law or practice.22Death Penalty Information Center. International Every other Western democracy has abandoned it. That isolation complicates extradition negotiations and strains diplomatic relationships. Within the United States, the direction is the same: twenty-three states and the District of Columbia have abolished the death penalty, and four more states hold executions in abeyance under gubernatorial moratoriums. The system that remains in the states that still use it is slow, expensive, uneven, and prone to killing innocent people. Those are the reasons it should go.