William Hutchinson: Criminal Cases, Civil Verdict, and Business Impact

Dallas real estate developer William “Bill” Hutchinson has faced both criminal charges and civil lawsuits over sexual assault allegations, and the cases have resolved in different ways. He pleaded guilty in April 2024 to a misdemeanor sexual battery count in California involving a 16-year-old girl; a Dallas County grand jury declined in 2022 to indict him on a separate Texas felony charge; and in June 2026, a Dallas civil jury found him liable for sexually assaulting two of three women who sued him and awarded $860,000 in combined damages.

The California Criminal Case

In July 2021, the Orange County District Attorney’s Office charged Hutchinson with one felony count of rape of an unconscious person and five misdemeanor counts of sexual battery. Prosecutors alleged he brought two 16-year-old girls to his Laguna Beach vacation home on separate trips, raping one while she was unconscious and committing sexual battery against both.¹ Hutchinson initially pleaded not guilty.²

On April 28, 2024, he pleaded guilty to a single count of misdemeanor sexual battery under a plea agreement. The remaining five charges, including the felony rape count, were dismissed; the Orange County District Attorney had reportedly declined to prosecute the felony because of insufficient evidence.³

The sentence was 90 days of home confinement served in Texas, three years of formal probation, a $150 fine, and 10-year sex offender registration.⁴ Earlier in 2026, the California conviction was expunged as part of the plea agreement. His defense attorney, Levi McCathern, said the expungement means Hutchinson is no longer required to register as a sex offender.⁵

The Texas Felony Charge That Did Not Result in Indictment

One day before the California charges became public, on July 7, 2021, Hutchinson turned himself in to Highland Park, Texas, police on a separate felony charge of sexual assault of a minor. The complaint came from a 17-year-old girl who alleged Hutchinson digitally penetrated her without consent while she was intoxicated at his Highland Park home.⁶ He was released on $30,000 bond.¹

On June 22, 2022, a Dallas County grand jury returned a no-bill, declining to indict him. Grand jury deliberations in Texas are confidential, so no reasoning was released.⁷ McCathern thanked investigators and said the outcome “established what I have always known — Bill Hutchinson is innocent.”⁸

The Dallas Civil Lawsuit

Three women filed a combined civil suit in Dallas County, each seeking more than $1 million. The first complaint was filed in July 2021, with the other two following the next year.⁵ All three alleged that Hutchinson assaulted them in the spring and summer of 2020 at properties he partly owned in the Dallas Design District, including the Virgin Hotel Dallas and Dunhill-managed apartments. Each said Hutchinson had offered to help with her career before the encounter.

The specific allegations differed:

Jane Doe 1 said she met Hutchinson at the Virgin Hotel for career advice, that he served her alcohol, took her to a nearby apartment, and groped her after she said no.⁹
Jane Doe 2 said Hutchinson forced himself on her on two occasions at the Virgin Hotel while she was drinking, and that she contracted an incurable sexually transmitted disease from the encounters.⁹
Jane Doe 3 said Hutchinson forced himself on her at his Dunhill apartments after they met at a political event, and that on another occasion she woke up in a Virgin Hotel room with Hutchinson present and no memory of how she got there.⁹

Two of the women also sued the Virgin Hotel and Dunhill Partners, alleging the businesses failed to protect them despite awareness of Hutchinson’s behavior.⁵ Judge Bridgett Whitmore dismissed the property defendants during trial, leaving Hutchinson as the only defendant.¹⁰

Defense at Trial

McCathern argued the suit was financially motivated, pointing out the plaintiffs had initially sought nearly $120 million before settling on lower figures. He introduced photos and text messages between Hutchinson and the women to challenge their accounts of the meetings as professional mentorship.¹¹ McCathern conceded his client was “a womanizer and a playboy” but maintained Hutchinson did not assault anyone and that the stories had “too many inconsistencies to be believed.”¹⁰

The Verdict

On June 25, 2026, after 11 hours of deliberation, the jury returned a split verdict. It found Hutchinson liable for sexually assaulting the two plaintiffs who alleged rape and awarded each $430,000, for a combined $860,000. Each award broke down as $100,000 for future medical expenses, $80,000 for past mental anguish, and $250,000 for future mental anguish. The jury rejected the claims of the third plaintiff, who had alleged groping.¹¹¹²

Whether Hutchinson Will Pay

After the verdict, McCathern said Hutchinson would not have to pay the $860,000, citing what he called the “one satisfaction rule.” Under that principle, settlement amounts previously paid by other defendants in the same lawsuit are credited against a later jury award. Because the damages fell below what the plaintiffs had already recovered from another defendant in an earlier settlement, McCathern said Hutchinson and his associated entities had “no financial liability as a result of yesterday’s verdict.”¹⁰

Effect on Hutchinson’s Business

After the 2021 allegations, Hutchinson stepped away from his roles at the Virgin Hotel Dallas and Dunhill Partners.¹³ In 2022, his firm sold three Design District properties, including the Dunhill Apartments at 1900 Hi Line Drive, in a sale tied to the civil litigation.¹⁴

Dunhill Partners continues to operate. As of 2026, the firm manages roughly 5 million square feet of retail property across the central and western United States, focused on grocery- and pharmacy-anchored shopping centers.¹⁵ In April 2026, Dunhill sold The Shops at Mockingbird, a 77,000-square-foot retail center near Highland Park, to Crow Holdings Capital, with Hutchinson calling the property a “crown jewel” of the firm’s portfolio.¹⁴ The firm has also been acquiring, picking up shopping centers in Dallas, Lubbock, and Brownwood, along with the 220,000-square-foot Greenville Promenade northeast of Dallas.¹⁶

1
Orange County District Attorney. Real Estate Developer Charged With Raping Unconscious Teenager While Vacationing in Laguna Beach
2
Fox 10 Phoenix. Marrying Millions Star Pleads Not Guilty to Raping Teen
3
D Magazine. Bill Hutchinson Pleads Guilty to Misdemeanor Sex Crime
4
Deadline. Marrying Millions Star William Hutchinson Pleads Guilty to Sexual Assault Charge
5
Dallas Morning News. Civil Trial for Dallas Developer Accused of Sex Assaults
6
Fox 4 News. Multiple Young Women Accuse North Texas Reality TV Star Bill Hutchinson of Sexual Assault
7
Dallas Morning News. Grand Jury Doesn’t Indict Dallas Developer Bill Hutchinson on Sexual Assault Charge
8
People Newspapers. Grand Jury Declines to Indict Bill Hutchinson
9
People Newspapers. Jury Deliberating in Bill Hutchinson Civil Trial Over Sexual Assault Allegations
10
Dallas Morning News. Jury Resumes Deliberations in Developer’s Sexual Assault Case
11
People Newspapers. Jury Reaches Verdict in Bill Hutchinson Sexual Assault Allegations Civil Trial
12
Texas Lawbook. Jury Sides With 2 of 3 Jane Does in Sexual Assault Trial Against Dallas Developer
13
D Magazine. The Rise and Fall of Virgin Hotel Developer Bill Hutchinson
14
The Real Deal. Bill Hutchinson Offloads Dallas Retail Amid Lawsuits
15
Dunhill Partners. What We Do
16
The Real Deal. Crow Holdings Scoops Up Love Field Shopping Center